应用GRADE进行诊断评级揭示方法学挑战:面向指南制定者的示例
该案例研究以IgE诊断过敏性鼻炎的附加价值为例,应用GRADE诊断方法评估完整检验-治疗策略的证据确定性。结果显示所有要素均缺乏高质量证据,且系统评价全部要素比仅考虑准确性更耗时。建议指南小组确定需系统评价的关键要素,非关键要素可依赖灰色文献与专业经验。
要点
- 完整检验-治疗策略各要素普遍缺乏高质量证据
- 系统评价全部要素耗时远超仅评价准确性
- 指南小组应确定需系统评价的关键要素以提高效率
核心结论
- 完整检验-治疗策略评估时高质量证据缺乏及时间投入大,对应用GRADE诊断方法构成挑战。
- 指南小组内讨论确定需评价的关键要素可能有助于应对挑战。
研究设计与样本
- 案例研究,应用GRADE for diagnosis评估IgE诊断过敏性鼻炎的附加价值。
- 评估完整检验-治疗策略各要素,包括诊断准确性、检验负担、管理效果、自然病程和关联证据。
主要发现
- 完整检验-治疗策略评估显示所有要素均缺乏(高质量)证据。
- 示例中发现检验负担、自然病程以及检验结果与临床管理之间的关联均缺乏证据。
- 系统评价全部要素比仅考虑检验准确性结果和管理效果更耗时。
关键数值与推荐
- 指南小组可确定检验-治疗策略中需要系统评价的关键要素以提高效率。
- 对非关键要素,指南小组可依赖灰色文献和专业经验。
临床怎么用
- 指南制定者应用GRADE for diagnosis时应讨论确定关键评价要素,对非关键要素可简化证据来源。
局限性
- 原文未明确报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To identify challenges in the application of GRADE for diagnosis when assessing the certainty of evidence in the test-treatment strategy (diagnostic accuracy, test burden, management effectiveness, natural course, linked evidence) in an illustrative example and to propose solutions to these challenges. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A case study in applying GRADE for diagnosis that looked at the added value of IgE for diagnosing allergic rhinitis. RESULTS: Evaluation of the full test-treatment strategy showed a lack of (high-quality) evidence for all elements. In our example, we found a lack of evidence for test burden, natural course, and link between the test result and clinical management. Overall, systematically reviewing the evidence for all elements of a test-treatment strategy is more time-consuming than only considering test accuracy results and management effectiveness. For increasing efficiency, the guideline panel could determine critical elements of the test-treatment strategy that need a systematic review of the evidence. For less critical elements, a guideline panel can rely on gray literature and professional expertise. CONCLUSION: A lack of high-quality evidence and time investment if the full test-treatment strategy is assessed, creating challenges in applying GRADE for diagnosis. Discussion within guideline panels about critical elements that need to be reviewed might help.
引用
- Tuut M, de Beer H, Burgers J, et al. Applying GRADE for diagnosis revealed methodological challenges: an illustrative example for guideline developers. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 33278615. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.11.021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。