健康素养、筛查与受试者选择对减少不健康零食行动计划的影响:澳大利亚随机对照试验
该两阶段随机对照试验在澳大利亚纳入1769名高BMI或2型糖尿病成人,比较三种行动计划分配方式(随机、健康素养筛查、受试者选择)与两种行动计划(标准版与素养敏感版)对减少不健康零食的影响。结果未发现分配方式有显著效应,素养敏感版对低健康素养者可能更有效但未达统计学显著。
要点
- 健康素养筛查分配方式与受试者选择相比,对减少不健康零食无显著差异。
- 素养敏感版行动计划对低健康素养者可能更有效,但差异未达统计学显著。
- 健康素养与行动计划类型的交互作用不显著(p=0.054)。
核心结论
- 观察到了按健康素养定制的行动计划在有效性上的名义改善,但未达到统计学显著。
- 与通用预防策略相比,此类策略的成本需进一步研究。
研究设计与样本
- 2019年2月14日至6月6日在澳大利亚进行的兩阶段随机对照试验,共纳入1769名高BMI或2型糖尿病成人。
- 参与者被随机分配至三种分配方式之一(随机、健康素养筛查、受试者选择)和两种行动计划之一(标准版与素养敏感版)。
- 采用回归分析评估健康素养(最新生命体征量表NVS)、分配方式和行动计划对4周随访时自报不健康零食份数减少的影响。
主要发现
- 随机分配组中完成随访者398人(67.7%),健康素养低于均值1个标准差者使用素养敏感版行动计划比标准版每周少摄入10.0份零食(95%CI:0.05至19.5;p=0.039)。
- 健康素养高于均值1个标准差者使用标准版比素养敏感版每周少摄入3.0份零食(95%CI:-6.3至12.2;p=0.529),差异未达统计学显著。
- 行动计划与健康素养(NVS)的交互作用不显著(b=-3.25;95%CI:-6.55至0.05;p=0.054)。
- 三种分配方式组中完成随访者共1177人(66.5%),分配方式对减少不健康零食无影响。
- 健康素养筛查与受试者选择相比无显著效应(b=1.79;95%CI:-0.16至3.73;p=0.067)。
关键数值与推荐
- 平均NVS得分为3.6分(满分6,SD=2.0)。
- 基线时参与者平均每周摄入25.0份零食(SD=28.0)。
临床怎么用
- 在减少不健康零食方面,尚未证明健康素养筛查分配优于受试者选择或随机分配。
- 对低健康素养人群可考虑使用素养敏感版行动计划,但需注意证据未达统计学显著。
局限性
- 随访保留率低至中等。
- 主要结局为单次自报测量。
- 报告了部分极端但 plausible 的零食摄入份数,增加了解释难度。
- 未评估不良事件。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Low health literacy is associated with poorer health outcomes. A key strategy to address health literacy is a universal precautions approach, which recommends using health-literate design for all health interventions, not just those targeting people with low health literacy. This approach has advantages: Health literacy assessment and tailoring are not required. However, action plans may be more effective when tailored by health literacy. This study evaluated the impact of health literacy and action plan type on unhealthy snacking for people who have high BMI or type 2 diabetes (Aim 1) and the most effective method of action plan allocation (Aim 2). METHODS AND FINDINGS: We performed a 2-stage randomised controlled trial in Australia between 14 February and 6 June 2019. In total, 1,769 participants (mean age: 49.8 years [SD = 11.7]; 56.1% female [n = 992]; mean BMI: 32.9 kg/m2 [SD = 8.7]; 29.6% self-reported type 2 diabetes [n = 523]) were randomised to 1 of 3 allocation methods (random, health literacy screening, or participant selection) and 1 of 2 action plans to reduce unhealthy snacking (standard versus literacy-sensitive). Regression analysis evaluated the impact of health literacy (Newest Vital Sign [NVS]), allocation method, and action plan on reduction in self-reported serves of unhealthy snacks (primary outcome) at 4-week follow-up. Secondary outcomes were perceived extent of unhealthy snacking, difficulty using the plans, habit strength, and action control. Analyses controlled for age, level of education, language spoken at home, diabetes status, baseline habit strength, and baseline self-reported serves of unhealthy snacks. Average NVS score was 3.6 out of 6 (SD = 2.0). Participants reported consuming 25.0 serves of snacks on average per week at baseline (SD = 28.0). Regarding Aim 1, 398 participants in the random allocation arm completed follow-up (67.7%). On average, people scoring 1 SD below the mean for health literacy consumed 10.0 fewer serves per week using the literacy-sensitive action plan compared to the standard action plan (95% CI: 0.05 to 19.5; p = 0.039), whereas those scoring 1 SD above the mean consumed 3.0 fewer serves using the standard action plan compared to the literacy-sensitive action plan (95% CI: -6.3 to 12.2; p = 0.529), although this difference did not reach statistical significance. In addition, we observed a non-significant action plan × health literacy (NVS) interaction (b = -3.25; 95% CI: -6.55 to 0.05; p = 0.054). Regarding Aim 2, 1,177 participants across the 3 allocation method arms completed follow-up (66.5%). There was no effect of allocation method on reduction of unhealthy snacking, including no effect of health literacy screening compared to participant selection (b = 1.79; 95% CI: -0.16 to 3.73; p = 0.067). Key limitations include low-moderate retention, use of a single-occasion self-reported primary outcome, and reporting of a number of extreme, yet plausible, snacking scores, which rendered interpretation more challenging. Adverse events were not assessed. CONCLUSIONS: In our study we observed nominal improvements in effectiveness of action plans tailored to health literacy; however, these improvements did not reach statistical significance, and the costs associated with such strategies compared with universal precautions need further investigation. This study highlights the importance of considering differential effects of health literacy on intervention effectiveness. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Australia and New Zealand Clinical Trial Registry ACTRN12618001409268.
引用
- Ayre J, Cvejic E, Bonner C, et al. Effects of health literacy, screening, and participant choice on action plans for reducing unhealthy snacking in Australia: A randomised controlled trial. PLoS Med. 2020. PMID: 33141834. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1003409
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。