极低事件率多中心临床试验的统计分析方法评估
针对54个中心五臂分层随机试验中低事件率导致零事件中心的问题,通过模拟研究和已完成RCT再分析比较五种估计比值比的方法。随机截距模型在多数场景表现最佳;GEE小样本校正适用于中心数较多时;不推荐Mantel-Haenszel、GEE或不校正中心的方法。
要点
- 随机截距模型在多数场景下表现最佳。
- GEE小样本校正在中心数较多时表现良好。
- 不推荐Mantel-Haenszel、GEE或不校正中心的方法。
核心结论
- 随机截距模型在大多数模拟场景中表现最佳。
- GEE小样本校正在中心数较多时表现良好。
- 不推荐使用Mantel-Haenszel、GEE或不校正中心的方法。
- 当预期事件率低时,建议统计分析计划中指定主方法不收敛时的替代方法。
研究设计与样本
- 模拟研究比较五种估计比值比的方法:不校正中心、随机截距模型、Mantel-Haenszel模型、GEE可交换相关结构、GEE小样本校正。
- 模拟参数变化包括总样本量(200、500、1000、5000)、中心数(5、50、100)、对照组事件百分比(2%、5%、10%)、真实比值比(1、>1)、组内相关系数(0.025、0.075)及参与者分布(均衡、偏斜)。
- 对一项已完成的多中心分层随机对照试验进行再分析。
主要发现
- Mantel-Haenszel方法在功效和偏倚方面通常表现较差,并因部分中心无事件而导致参与者被排除分析。
- 不校正中心的分析通常导致较低的功效和I类错误率,尤其在ICC=0.075时。
- GEE的I类错误率膨胀,除非在中心数较多的某些场景。
- GEE小样本校正在中心数较少时存在功效降低和收敛问题,但维持I类错误率在名义水平。
- 随机截距模型在多数场景表现良好,但在事件率低(2%)且总样本量小(n≤500)时所有方法均有问题。
临床怎么用
- 在极低事件率的多中心试验中,优先考虑随机截距模型进行中心校正分析。
- 当中心数较多时,可考虑使用GEE小样本校正方法。
- 避免使用Mantel-Haenszel、GEE或不校正中心的方法。
- 在统计分析计划中预先指定主分析方法不收敛时的替代方案。
局限性
- 在事件率低(2%)且总样本量小(n≤500)时,所有评估方法均存在问题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: In a five-arm randomized clinical trial (RCT) with stratified randomization across 54 sites, we encountered low primary outcome event proportions, resulting in multiple sites with zero events either overall or in one or more study arms. In this paper, we systematically evaluated different statistical methods of accounting for center in settings with low outcome event proportions. METHODS: We conducted a simulation study and a reanalysis of a completed RCT to compare five popular methods of estimating an odds ratio for multicenter trials with stratified randomization by center: (i) no center adjustment, (ii) random intercept model, (iii) Mantel-Haenszel model, (iv) generalized estimating equation (GEE) with an exchangeable correlation structure, and (v) GEE with small sample correction (GEE-small sample correction). We varied the number of total participants (200, 500, 1000, 5000), number of centers (5, 50, 100), control group outcome percentage (2%, 5%, 10%), true odds ratio (1, > 1), intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) (0.025, 0.075), and distribution of participants across the centers (balanced, skewed). RESULTS: Mantel-Haenszel methods generally performed poorly in terms of power and bias and led to the exclusion of participants from the analysis because some centers had no events. Failure to account for center in the analysis generally led to lower power and type I error rates than other methods, particularly with ICC = 0.075. GEE had an inflated type I error rate except in some settings with a large number of centers. GEE-small sample correction maintained the type I error rate at the nominal level but suffered from reduced power and convergence issues in some settings when the number of centers was small. Random intercept models generally performed well in most scenarios, except with a low event rate (i.e., 2% scenario) and small total sample size (n ≤ 500), when all methods had issues. DISCUSSION: Random intercept models generally performed best across most scenarios. GEE-small sample correction performed well when the number of centers was large. We do not recommend the use of Mantel-Haenszel, GEE, or models that do not account for center. When the expected event rate is low, we suggest that the statistical analysis plan specify an alternative method in the case of non-convergence of the primary method.
引用
- Kim J, Troxel AB, Halpern SD, et al. Analysis of multicenter clinical trials with very low event rates. Trials. 2020. PMID: 33168073. doi:10.1186/s13063-020-04801-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。