用务实照护试验实践基于结局的医疗照护
本文讨论研究与临床实践分离的问题,提出务实照护试验(将随机对照整合入照护、按患者最佳医学利益设计)可验证干预是否带来良好结局并在不确定时优化照护。作者报告单中心9项随机照护试验,指导1212例急性卒中、颅内动脉瘤和动静脉畸形的血管内或外科治疗,将不可验证的教条式实践转变为可验证的基于结局的医疗。
要点
- 务实照护试验将随机分配整合入临床照护,设计以患者最佳医学利益为准则。
- 单中心9项照护试验指导1212例卒中、动脉瘤和动静脉畸形的血管内或外科治疗。
- 在缺乏可靠知识时以1:1随机分配替代不可重复的治疗决策,可即时改变实践。
核心结论
- 务实照护试验可在缺乏可靠知识时用1:1随机分配替代不可重复的治疗决策,把不可验证的教条式医疗转变为可验证的基于结局的照护。
- 作者认为该方法可适用于所有内科或外科领域,但广泛采用可能需要修正当前关于研究在临床实践中作用的许多流行观点。
研究设计与样本
- 报告单中心开展的9项随机照护试验,用于指导急性卒中、颅内动脉瘤和动静脉畸形的血管内或外科管理。
- 照护试验为整合入照护的全纳入随机试验,每项试验设计均按参与患者的最佳医学利益选择。
主要发现
- 9项随机照护试验在择期或急性照护情境下指导了1212例患者的血管内或外科管理。
- 照护试验用于解决关于竞争性内科、外科或血管内管理选项的长期困境,或提供创新而非标准治疗。
临床怎么用
- 在无可靠知识时,可用1:1随机分配替代不可重复的治疗决策,以即时影响并优化医疗照护。
- 照护试验最终可基于患者结局显示何为良好医疗实践。
局限性
- 报告来自单中心经验,广泛推广可能需修正当前关于研究在临床实践中作用的流行观点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The current separation between medical research and care is an obstacle to essential aspects of good medical practice: the verification that care interventions actually deliver the good outcomes they promise, and the use of scientific methods to optimize care under uncertainty. Pragmatic care trials have been designed to address these problems. Care trials are all-inclusive randomized trials integrated into care. Every item of trial design is selected in the best medical interest of participating patients. Care trials can eventually show what constitutes good medical practice based on patient outcomes. In the meantime, care trials give clinicians and patients the scientific methods necessary for optimization of medical care when no one really knows what to do.We report the progress of 9 randomized care trials that were used to guide the endovascular or surgical management of 1212 patients with acute stroke, intracranial aneurysms, and arteriovenous malformations in a single center in an elective or acute care context. Care trials were used to address long-standing dilemmas regarding rival medical, surgical, or endovascular management options or to offer innovative instead of standard treatments. The trial methodology, by replacing unrepeatable treatment decisions by 1:1 randomized allocation whenever reliable knowledge was not available, had an immediate impact, transforming unverifiable dogmatic medical practice into verifiable outcome-based medical care. We believe the approach is applicable to all medical or surgical domains, but widespread adoption may require the revision of many currently prevalent views regarding the role of research in clinical practice.
引用
- Darsaut TE, Raymond J. Practicing outcome-based medical care using pragmatic care trials. Trials. 2020. PMID: 33121523. doi:10.1186/s13063-020-04829-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。