马尔可夫链方法用于网状Meta分析中的治疗排序
针对网状Meta分析(NMA)中数据局限性和定性判断难以纳入排序的问题,作者提出一种新指标POST-R(选择推荐治疗的概率),将治疗排序视为马尔可夫链选择过程,可结合NMA结果与外部信息。以慢性斑块状银屑病NMA为例演示并给出Stata命令。
要点
- POST-R将治疗排序建模为马尔可夫链选择过程,可纳入NMA结果之外的信息。
- 该方法使排序同时反映相对效应与潜在局限性,辅助决策。
- 以慢性斑块状银屑病NMA为例演示,并提供Stata命令。
核心结论
- 提出POST-R指标,将治疗排序视为马尔可夫链选择过程,可结合NMA结果与外部信息进行排序。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学文章,提出新排序指标POST-R并以慢性斑块状银屑病NMA为例演示,提供Stata命令。
主要发现
- POST-R为每个治疗分配被选中的概率,排序可反映相对效应及其潜在局限性。
临床怎么用
- NMA使用者可基于POST-R结合NMA结果与外部信息选择最合适的治疗。
局限性
- 部分局限性(如偏倚风险、小样本效应、发表偏倚)在数据缺失时无法正式纳入排序。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
When interpreting the relative effects from a network meta-analysis (NMA), researchers are usually aware of the potential limitations that may render the results for some comparisons less useful or meaningless. In the presence of sufficient and appropriate data, some of these limitations (eg, risk of bias, small-study effects, publication bias) can be taken into account in the statistical analysis. Very often, though, the necessary data for applying these methods are missing and data limitations cannot be formally integrated into ranking. In addition, there are other important characteristics of the treatment comparisons that cannot be addressed within a statistical model but only through qualitative judgments; for example, the relevance of data to the research question, the plausibility of the assumptions, and so on. Here, we propose a new measure for treatment ranking called the Probability of Selecting a Treatment to Recommend (POST-R). We suggest that the order of treatments should represent the process of considering treatments for selection in clinical practice and we assign to each treatment a probability of being selected. This process can be considered as a Markov chain model that allows the end-users of NMA to select the most appropriate treatments based not only on the NMA results but also to information external to the NMA. In this way, we obtain rankings that can inform decision-making more efficiently as they represent not only the relative effects but also their potential limitations. We illustrate our approach using a NMA comparing treatments for chronic plaque psoriasis and we provide the Stata commands.
引用
- Chaimani A, Porcher R, Sbidian É, et al. A Markov chain approach for ranking treatments in network meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2020. PMID: 33105517. doi:10.1002/sim.8784
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。