文献速递临床试验与 GCP基础与转化研究

助产连续性照护与标准产科照护对早产风险增加孕妇的混合实施-效果随机对照预试验

Midwifery continuity of care versus standard maternity care for women at increased risk of preterm birth: A hybrid implementation-effectiveness, randomised controlled pilot trial in the UK.
PubMed 文献 · PLoS Med · 2020-10-06

本研究在英国伦敦内城产科开展混合实施-效果、随机、对照、非盲、平行组预试验,将早产风险增加的孕妇按1:1随机分配至助产连续性照护联合专科产科门诊模式(POPPIE组)或标准照护组,评估可行性、保真度和临床结局。共招募334名孕妇,主要复合结局两组无统计学显著差异(83.3% vs 84.7%;RR 0.98 [95%CI 0.90-1.08];p=0.742),但POPPIE组婴儿出生后皮肤接触和母乳喂养更优。结论:该模式可行且保真度好,但对该人群多数结局无影响,需更大样本试验。

要点

  • 助产连续性照护联合专科产科模式在早产风险增加孕妇中可行且保真度好。
  • 主要复合结局两组无显著差异(83.3% vs 84.7%;RR 0.98 [95%CI 0.90-1.08];p=0.742)。
  • POPPIE组婴儿出生后皮肤接触和母乳喂养显著更优,其他次要结局无差异。

核心结论

  • 在伦敦内城产科,为早产风险增加孕妇建立助产连续性照护联合专科产科照护模式可行且保真度好,但对该人群多数结局无影响。
  • 需要更大样本、适当把握度的试验,在其他环境评估关系连续性及基于信任、参与、协调和转诊的假定机制对弱势社区的影响。

研究设计与样本

  • 混合实施-效果、随机、对照、非盲、平行组预试验,在英国伦敦内城产科服务开展。
  • 2017年5月9日至2018年9月30日招募334名孕妇,随机1:1分配至POPPIE组(169例)或标准照护组(165例)。
  • 纳入标准:孕周小于24周且满足以下至少一项:既往宫颈手术、环扎、胎膜早破、早产或晚期流产;既往或本次妊娠宫颈短;子宫异常和/或当前吸烟。
  • 主要结局为预防和/或管理早产及分娩的适当及时干预的复合结局,按意向性治疗分析。

主要发现

  • 主要复合结局发生率两组无统计学显著差异(POPPIE组83.3% vs 标准组84.7%;RR 0.98 [95%CI 0.90-1.08];p=0.742)。
  • POPPIE组婴儿出生后皮肤接触显著更可能、时间更长,且出生后即刻和出院时母乳喂养显著更优。
  • 其他次要结局无差异;严重不良事件两组相似(POPPIE组6例 vs 标准组5例),与干预无关。
  • 超过75%的产前和产后访视由指定/伙伴助产士提供,80%的分娩有POPPIE团队助产士在场。

临床怎么用

  • 该模式可作为早产风险增加孕妇的可行照护选项,尤其可能改善母婴早期接触和母乳喂养。
  • 但现有证据不支持该模式能改善多数临床结局,需更大规模试验验证。

局限性

  • 研究把握度有限。
  • 分组分配未设盲(但统计师和分析数据的研究者设盲)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Midwifery continuity of care is the only health system intervention shown to reduce preterm birth (PTB) and improve perinatal survival, but no trial evidence exists for women with identified risk factors for PTB. We aimed to assess feasibility, fidelity, and clinical outcomes of a model of midwifery continuity of care linked with a specialist obstetric clinic for women considered at increased risk for PTB. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We conducted a hybrid implementation-effectiveness, randomised, controlled, unblinded, parallel-group pilot trial at an inner-city maternity service in London (UK), in which pregnant women identified at increased risk of PTB were randomly assigned (1:1) to either midwifery continuity of antenatal, intrapartum, and postnatal care (Pilot study Of midwifery Practice in Preterm birth Including women's Experiences [POPPIE] group) or standard care group (maternity care by different midwives working in designated clinical areas). Pregnant women attending for antenatal care at less than 24 weeks' gestation were eligible if they fulfilled one or more of the following criteria: previous cervical surgery, cerclage, premature rupture of membranes, PTB, or late miscarriage; previous short cervix or short cervix this pregnancy; or uterine abnormality and/or current smoker of tobacco. Feasibility outcomes included eligibility, recruitment and attrition rates, and fidelity of the model. The primary outcome was a composite of appropriate and timely interventions for the prevention and/or management of preterm labour and birth. We analysed by intention to treat. Between 9 May 2017 and 30 September 2018, 334 women were recruited; 169 women were allocated to the POPPIE group and 165 to the standard group. Mean maternal age was 31 years; 32% of the women were from Black, Asian, and ethnic minority groups; 70% were in employment; and 46% had a university degree. Nearly 70% of women lived in areas of social deprivation. More than a quarter of women had at least one pre-existing medical condition and multiple risk factors for PTB. More than 75% of antenatal and postnatal visits were provided by a named/partner midwife, and a midwife from the POPPIE team was present at 80% of births. The incidence of the primary composite outcome showed no statistically significant difference between groups (POPPIE group 83.3% versus standard group 84.7%; risk ratio 0.98 [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.90 to 1.08]; p = 0.742). Infants in the POPPIE group were significantly more likely to have skin-to-skin contact after birth, to have it for a longer time, and to breastfeed immediately after birth and at hospital discharge. There were no differences in other secondary outcomes. The number of serious adverse events was similar in both groups and unrelated to the intervention (POPPIE group 6 versus standard group 5). Limitations of this study included the limited power and the nonmasking of group allocation; however, study assignment was masked to the statistician and researchers who analysed the data. CONCLUSIONS: In this study, we found that it is feasible to set up and achieve fidelity of a model of midwifery continuity of care linked with specialist obstetric care for women at increased risk of PTB in an inner-city maternity service in London (UK), but there is no impact on most outcomes for this population group. Larger appropriately powered trials are needed, including in other settings, to evaluate the impact of relational continuity and hypothesised mechanisms of effect based on increased trust and engagement, improved care coordination, and earlier referral on disadvantaged communities, including women with complex social factors and social vulnerability. TRIAL REGISTRATION: We prospectively registered the pilot trial on the UK Clinical Research Network Portfolio Database (ID number: 31951, 24 April 2017). We registered the trial on the International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number (ISRCTN) (Number: 37733900, 21 August 2017) and before trial recruitment was completed (30 September 2018) when informed that prospective registration for a pilot trial was also required in a primary clinical trial registry recognised by WHO and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). The protocol as registered and published has remained unchanged, and the analysis conforms to the original plan.

来源:PLoS Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fernandez Turienzo C, Bick D, Briley AL, et al. Midwifery continuity of care versus standard maternity care for women at increased risk of preterm birth: A hybrid implementation-effectiveness, randomised controlled pilot trial in the UK. PLoS Med. 2020. PMID: 33022010. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1003350

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。