研究者手册中既往临床研究的报告未遵循证据合成基本原则:一项横断面研究
该横断面研究评估了德国某伦理委员会审阅的97份I/II期试验研究者手册(IB)对既往临床研究证据合成的依从性,并对其中30份IB的247项既往研究进行报告质量评价。结果显示仅2%的IB报告了全面检索策略、批判性评价或结构化呈现结果,且评估偏倚风险所需信息很少报告。
要点
- 仅2%的IB报告了全面检索策略、批判性评价或结构化结果呈现。
- IB汇编的既往临床研究中,评估偏倚风险所需信息很少报告。
- IB未遵循证据合成基本原则,可能影响风险-获益评估的可信度与效率。
核心结论
- IB在汇编支持拟议临床研究理由的所有可用证据时,未承认广泛建立的证据审查与报告原则。
- 这可能对风险-获益评估的可信度和效率产生负面影响。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,评估德国某研究伦理委员会审阅的97份I/II期试验IB对既往临床研究检索、评价和合成程序的报告情况。
- 对随机抽取的30份IB中汇编的247项既往临床研究进行报告质量评价。
主要发现
- 97份IB中仅2%报告了全面检索策略、对汇编的既往临床研究提供批判性评价或以结构化方式呈现相应研究结果。
- 30份IB中汇编的247项既往临床研究中,评估偏倚风险所需信息(如样本量计算或基线特征)很少报告。
临床怎么用
- IB撰写时应遵循证据合成基本原则,报告全面检索策略、批判性评价和结构化结果呈现。
- 应充分报告评估既往研究偏倚风险所需的信息,如样本量计算和基线特征。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: International regulations require Investigator's Brochures (IBs) to compile all available evidence that inform the risk-benefit assessment for the newly planned clinical trial. This study examined the adherence of IBs to the basic principles of evidence synthesis when compiling prior clinical studies. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: For 97 IBs for phase I/II trials reviewed at one German research ethics committee we assessed the reporting on search, appraisal, and synthesis procedures for prior clinical studies. For a random subsample of 30 IBs, we evaluated the quality of reporting of the compiled 247 prior clinical studies. RESULTS: Only 2% of all 97 IBs reported a comprehensive search strategy, provided a critical appraisal of the compiled prior clinical studies or presented respective study results in a structured manner. For the 247 prior clinical studies compiled in 30 IBs, the information required to appraise their risk of bias (eg, sample size calculation or baseline characteristics) was rarely reported. CONCLUSION: When compiling all available evidence supporting the rationale for the proposed clinical study IBs do not acknowledge the broadly established principles for reviewing and reporting evidence. This may impact negatively on the trustworthiness and efficiency of risk-benefit assessment.
引用
- Schwietering J, Strech D, Bittlinger M, et al. Reporting of prior clinical studies in Investigator's Brochures did not adhere to the basic principles of evidence synthesis: a cross-sectional study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32991993. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.09.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。