简化与全面文献检索的Meta流行病学研究
该Meta流行病学研究比较了基于简化检索与全面检索的Meta分析效应估计的一致性:简化47个Cochrane综述的检索并生成658次新检索,与原始Meta分析比较。结果显示简化检索常得到相同或非常相似的效应估计,但置信区间略增,且可能出现方向相反或无法估计的偏倚。
要点
- 简化检索在34-79%的Meta分析中产生相同效应估计,15-51%方向与显著性相同但数值不同,6-13%出现相反效应或无法估计。
- 效应量偏差在50%的Meta分析中为零,75%不超过1.07倍;简化检索的标准误增大1.02-1.06倍。
- 简化检索的效应估计未系统性偏大或偏小(中位OR比1,IQR 1-1.01),但可能出现相关偏倚。
核心结论
- 简化文献检索常得到与全面检索相同或非常相似的效应估计,但置信区间略宽,相关偏倚可能发生。
研究设计与样本
- Meta流行病学研究,简化47个Cochrane综述的全面检索,生成658次新检索,比较每个综述中一个原始Meta分析与基于简化检索重新计算的Meta分析。
主要发现
- 47个原始Meta分析纳入444项试验(中位6项/综述,IQR 3-11),共360045名受试者(中位1371名/综述,IQR 685-8041)。
- 简化检索在34-79%的Meta分析中效应估计相同,15-51%方向与统计显著性水平相同但数值不同,6-13%出现相反效应或无法估计。
- 效应量偏差在50%的Meta分析中为零,75%不超过1.07倍;简化检索的标准误增大1.02-1.06倍。
- 简化检索的效应估计未一致偏大或偏小(中位OR比1,IQR 1-1.01)。
临床怎么用
- 在系统综述/Meta分析中,可考虑简化检索以节省资源,但需注意置信区间可能略增且存在相关偏倚风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to assess the agreement of treatment effect estimates from meta-analyses based on abbreviated or comprehensive literature searches. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: This was a meta-epidemiological study. We abbreviated 47 comprehensive Cochrane review searches and searched MEDLINE/Embase/CENTRAL alone, in combination, with/without checking references (658 new searches). We compared one meta-analysis from each review with recalculated ones based on abbreviated searches. RESULTS: The 47 original meta-analyses included 444 trials (median 6 per review [interquartile range (IQR) 3-11]) with 360045 participants (median 1,371 per review [IQR 685-8,041]). Depending on the search approach, abbreviated searches led to identical effect estimates in 34-79% of meta-analyses, to different effect estimates with the same direction and level of statistical significance in 15-51%, and to opposite effects (or effects could not be estimated anymore) in 6-13%. The deviation of effect sizes was zero in 50% of the meta-analyses and in 75% not larger than 1.07-fold. Effect estimates of abbreviated searches were not consistently smaller or larger (median ratio of odds ratio 1 [IQR 1-1.01]) but more imprecise (1.02-1.06-fold larger standard errors). CONCLUSION: Abbreviated literature searches often led to identical or very similar effect estimates as comprehensive searches with slightly increased confidence intervals. Relevant deviations may occur.
引用
- Ewald H, Klerings I, Wagner G, et al. Abbreviated and comprehensive literature searches led to identical or very similar effect estimates: a meta-epidemiological study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32781114. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.08.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。