临床试验复发事件终点伴时间趋势的盲态连续信息监测
针对基于盲态数据的样本量重估与信息监测,本文在前期过分散计数数据连续监测方法基础上,提出两种适应事件率时间趋势的盲态方法:混合法与合并法。模拟显示在事件率下降时,两种监测程序第一类错误率未见明显膨胀(强时间依赖下恒定率法有膨胀),且适应时间趋势的方法检验效能优于恒定率法。
要点
- 盲态连续信息监测可适应事件率时间趋势,控制第一类错误。
- 恒定事件率假设在强时间依赖下会导致第一类错误膨胀。
- 适应时间趋势的方法较恒定率法检验效能更优,后者常停止过晚。
核心结论
- 在事件率存在时间趋势时,应采用适应时间趋势的盲态监测程序,而非恒定事件率假设下的程序。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,扩展过分散计数数据的盲态连续监测程序,提出混合法与合并法两种盲态方法,并以儿童多发性硬化随机对照试验为例说明。
- 通过模拟在事件率下降情形下考察所提程序的操作特征。
主要发现
- 两种监测程序均未明显膨胀第一类错误率,例外是强时间依赖下假定恒定率的程序出现一定膨胀。
- 适应时间趋势的程序总体检验效能优于基于恒定率的程序,后者常停止过晚。
临床怎么用
- 在临床试验盲态样本量重估与信息监测中,应考虑事件率时间趋势并选用相应方法。
局限性
- 模拟仅考察事件率下降情形,方法学结论的外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Blinded sample size re-estimation and information monitoring based on blinded data has been suggested to mitigate risks due to planning uncertainties regarding nuisance parameters. Motivated by a randomized controlled trial in pediatric multiple sclerosis (MS), a continuous monitoring procedure for overdispersed count data was proposed recently. However, this procedure assumed constant event rates, an assumption often not met in practice. Here we extend the procedure to accommodate time trends in the event rates considering two blinded approaches: (a) the mixture approach modeling the number of events by a mixture of two negative binomial distributions and (b) the lumping approach approximating the marginal distribution of the event counts by a negative binomial distribution. Through simulations the operating characteristics of the proposed procedures are investigated under decreasing event rates. We find that the type I error rate is not inflated relevantly by either of the monitoring procedures, with the exception of strong time dependencies where the procedure assuming constant rates exhibits some inflation. Furthermore, the procedure accommodating time trends has generally favorable power properties compared with the procedure based on constant rates which stops often too late. The proposed method is illustrated by the clinical trial in pediatric MS.
引用
- Mütze T, Salem S, Benda N, et al. Blinded continuous information monitoring of recurrent event endpoints with time trends in clinical trials. Stat Med. 2020. PMID: 32815175. doi:10.1002/sim.8702
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。