腰痛物理治疗随机试验的方法学质量系统综述
该系统综述基于PEDro数据库识别2215项物理治疗干预腰痛(任何病程或类型、任何年龄)的随机对照试验,采用既有PEDro评分评估方法学质量。多数试验为成人(2136项,96.4%)、非特异性腰痛(1863项,84.1%)、慢性病程(947项,42.8%);质量随时间改善,但多数仍存在偏倚风险。结论认为多数试验存在可能使疗效估计产生偏倚的方法学局限,应更重视分配隐藏与意向性治疗效应报告。
要点
- 多数腰痛物理治疗试验存在偏倚风险,疗效估计可能被高估或扭曲。
- 分配隐藏(36.7%)、意向性治疗(35.1%)、盲法评估者(36.6%)实施比例偏低。
- 盲法参与者和治疗师实施比例极低(7.9%、1.8%),各疗法类型间无差异。
核心结论
- 多数测试腰痛物理治疗干预的试验存在可能使疗效估计产生偏倚的方法学局限。
- 更重视分配隐藏与意向性治疗效应报告,可提升此类试验的质量。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索Physiotherapy Evidence Database(PEDro)收录的物理治疗预防或治疗腰痛的随机对照试验,不限病程、类型与年龄。
- 共识别2215项试验,使用既有PEDro量表评分评估方法学质量。
主要发现
- 成人试验2136项(96.4%),非特异性腰痛1863项(84.1%),慢性病程947项(42.8%)。
- 试验质量随时间改善,但多数仍处于偏倚风险。
- 分配隐藏813项(36.7%),意向性治疗778项(35.1%),盲法评估者810项(36.6%),盲法参与者174项(7.9%),盲法治疗师39项(1.8%)。
- 上述结果不随治疗类型而变化。
临床怎么用
- 解读腰痛物理治疗试验结果时,应关注分配隐藏、意向性治疗与盲法实施情况,警惕偏倚对疗效估计的影响。
- 开展此类试验时应优先落实分配隐藏与意向性治疗分析并规范报告。
局限性
- 方法学质量采用既有PEDro量表评分,未另行独立重新评价。
- 仅纳入PEDro数据库收录的试验,可能存在选择偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to review and assess the methodological quality of randomized controlled trials that test physical therapy interventions for low back pain. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: This is a systematic review of trials of physical therapy interventions to prevent or treat low back pain (of any duration or type) in participants of any age indexed on the Physiotherapy Evidence Database (PEDro). Existing PEDro scale ratings were used to evaluate methodological quality. RESULTS: This review identified 2,215 trials. The majority of trials were for adults (n = 2136, 96.4%), low back pain without specific etiology (n = 1,863, 84.1%), and chronic duration (n = 947, 42.8%). The quality of trials improved over time; however, most were at risk of bias. Less than half of the trials concealed allocation to intervention (n = 813, 36.7%), used intention-to-treat principles (n = 778, 35.1%), and blinded assessors (n = 810, 36.6%), participants (n = 174, 7.9%), and therapists (n = 39, 1.8%). These findings did not vary by the type of therapy. CONCLUSION: Most trials that test physical therapy interventions for low back pain have methodological limitations that could bias treatment effect estimates. Greater attention to methodological features, such as allocation concealment and the reporting of intention-to-treat effects, would improve the quality of trials testing physical therapy interventions for low back pain.
引用
- Cashin AG, Lee H, Bagg MK, et al. A systematic review highlights the need to improve the quality and applicability of trials of physical therapy interventions for low back pain. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32603685. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.06.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。