评估基于锚定的患者报告结局最小重要差异估计的可信度:工具开发与信度研究
本研究开发了评估基于锚定的患者报告结局最小重要差异(MID)估计可信度的工具,并评估其信度。工具包含五个核心标准及过渡评分锚的附加标准,评分者间信度系数(ĸ)在核心标准和一项附加标准上为0.70至0.94。该工具可供研究者、临床医生和卫生政策决策者用于评估MID估计研究的设计、实施和分析。
要点
- 开发了评估基于锚定MID估计可信度的工具,含五个核心标准。
- 过渡评分锚另有附加标准,但部分因报告问题未能评估信度。
- 核心标准及一项附加标准的评分者间信度系数为0.70至0.94。
核心结论
- 研究者、临床医生和卫生政策决策者可考虑使用该工具评估基于锚定MID估计研究的设计、实施和分析。
研究设计与样本
- 工具开发与信度研究,基于文献综述(Medline、Embase、CINAHL和PsycInfo数据库)和作者经验制定初始标准,经团队迭代讨论及专家预试验形成最终工具。
- 由具有健康研究方法学背景的硕士、博士或博士后学生配对独立评估MID估计样本的可信度。
主要发现
- 可信度工具包含五个核心标准:锚由患者评定;锚可解释且与患者相关;MID估计精确;锚与患者报告结局指标间的相关性令人满意;作者选择反映小但重要差异的锚阈值。
- 过渡评分锚的附加标准为:MID估计的基线与随访测量间时间间隔最佳;过渡评分与患者报告结局指标的基线、随访和变化评分间的相关性令人满意。
- 核心标准及一项附加标准的评分者间信度系数(ĸ)范围为0.70至0.94。
- 报告问题导致无法评估过渡评分锚其他三项附加标准的信度。
关键数值与推荐
- 核心标准五条:锚由患者评定;锚可解释且与患者相关;MID估计精确;锚与患者报告结局指标相关性满意;选择反映小但重要差异的锚阈值。
- 过渡评分锚附加标准:MID估计的基线与随访测量间时间间隔最佳;过渡评分与患者报告结局指标的基线、随访和变化评分相关性满意。
- 核心标准及一项附加标准的评分者间信度系数(ĸ)为0.70至0.94。
临床怎么用
- 研究者、临床医生和卫生政策决策者可用该工具评估基于锚定MID估计研究的设计、实施和分析。
局限性
- 报告问题导致无法评估过渡评分锚三项附加标准的信度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To develop an instrument to evaluate the credibility of anchor based minimal important differences (MIDs) for outcome measures reported by patients, and to assess the reliability of the instrument. DESIGN: Instrument development and reliability study. DATA SOURCES: Initial criteria were developed for evaluating the credibility of anchor based MIDs based on a literature review (Medline, Embase, CINAHL, and PsycInfo databases) and the experience of the authors in the methodology for estimation of MIDs. Iterative discussions by the team and pilot testing with experts and potential users facilitated the development of the final instrument. PARTICIPANTS: With the newly developed instrument, pairs of masters, doctoral, or postdoctoral students with a background in health research methodology independently evaluated the credibility of a sample of MID estimates. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Core credibility criteria applicable to all anchor types, additional criteria for transition rating anchors, and inter-rater reliability coefficients were determined. RESULTS: The credibility instrument has five core criteria: the anchor is rated by the patient; the anchor is interpretable and relevant to the patient; the MID estimate is precise; the correlation between the anchor and the outcome measure reported by the patient is satisfactory; and the authors select a threshold on the anchor that reflects a small but important difference. The additional criteria for transition rating anchors are: the time elapsed between baseline and follow-up measurement for estimation of the MID is optimal; and the correlations of the transition rating with the baseline, follow-up, and change score in the patient reported outcome measures are satisfactory. Inter-rater reliability coefficients (ĸ) for the core criteria and for one item from the additional criteria ranged from 0.70 to 0.94. Reporting issues prevented the evaluation of the reliability of the three other additional criteria for the transition rating anchors. CONCLUSIONS: Researchers, clinicians, and healthcare policy decision makers can consider using this instrument to evaluate the design, conduct, and analysis of studies estimating anchor based minimal important differences.
引用
- Devji T, Carrasco-Labra A, Qasim A, et al. Evaluating the credibility of anchor based estimates of minimal important differences for patient reported outcomes: instrument development and reliability study. BMJ. 2020. PMID: 32499297. doi:10.1136/bmj.m1714
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。