亚组分析为何只见树木不见森林:一项模拟研究
该研究探讨临床试验亚组分析可能因选择偏倚而得出不适用于源人群的亚组效应估计。作者使用有向无环图展示效应修饰因子与试验选择(明确或隐含)的关联如何导致系统性偏倚,并通过假设示例说明错误结论及其后果。结论认为即使分析严谨且内部有效,将试验亚组视为源人群对应亚组的随机样本仍可能产生误导。
要点
- 效应修饰因子与试验选择的关联可导致亚组估计偏离源人群真实效应。
- 亚组分析即使内部有效,外推至源人群对应亚组仍需谨慎。
- 研究者应检查并考虑调整效应修饰因子与选择变量的关联。
核心结论
- 将试验内亚组视为源人群对应亚组的随机样本可能产生误导,即使分析严谨且内部有效。
研究设计与样本
- 模拟研究,使用有向无环图展示选择偏倚导致亚组估计偏离源人群效应的机制,并提供假设示例及探索工具。
主要发现
- 效应修饰因子与试验选择(明确如 eligibility criteria 或隐含如基于种族的自选择)的关联可导致亚组估计不对应源人群亚组效应。
- 假设示例展示了此类错误结论及其潜在后果。
临床怎么用
- 研究者应仔细检查效应修饰因子与选择变量的关联,并在识别异质性治疗效应时考虑调整。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Subgroup analyses of clinical trial data can be an important tool for understanding when treatment effects differ across populations. That said, even effect estimates from prespecified subgroups in well-conducted trials may not apply to corresponding subgroups in the source population. While this divergence may simply reflect statistical imprecision, there has been less discussion of systematic or structural sources of misleading subgroup estimates. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We use directed acyclic graphs to show how selection bias caused by associations between effect measure modifiers and trial selection, whether explicit (e.g., eligibility criteria) or implicit (e.g., self-selection based on race), can result in subgroup estimates that do not correspond to subgroup effects in the source population. To demonstrate this point, we provide a hypothetical example illustrating the sorts of erroneous conclusions that can result, as well as their potential consequences. We also provide a tool for readers to explore additional cases. CONCLUSION: Treating subgroups within a trial essentially as random samples of the corresponding subgroups in the wider population can be misleading, even when analyses are conducted rigorously and all findings are internally valid. Researchers should carefully examine associations between (and consider adjusting for) variables when attempting to identify heterogeneous treatment effects.
引用
- Webster-Clark M, Baron JA, Jonsson Funk M, et al. How subgroup analyses can miss the trees for the forest plots: A simulation study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32565216. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.06.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。