成人住院患者病情恶化预警评分:系统综述与方法学批判性评估
该系统综述检索Medline、CINAHL、PsycInfo和Embase至2019年6月,纳入95篇文献,评估成人住院患者早期预警评分的开发与外验证方法学。多数评分以死亡为预测结局,呼吸频率等生命体征为常见预测因子,但分析人群细节报告不足、样本量小、缺失数据处理不当,仅少数评分报告校准度,全部研究存在高偏倚风险。
要点
- 预警评分开发与外验证普遍存在方法学缺陷,全部研究高偏倚风险。
- 死亡是最常见预测结局,多数时间窗为24小时,呼吸频率最常见预测因子。
- 校准度评估罕见,仅15%外验证研究评估校准度,可能影响临床安全性。
核心结论
- 早期预警评分广泛用于临床但方法学薄弱,可能无法达到预期性能并对患者照护产生不利影响。
- 未来应遵循推荐方法开发与评价预警评分,并研究其临床影响与安全性。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入研究类型:11篇仅开发、23篇开发与外验证、61篇仅外验证。
主要发现
- 死亡是开发研究(10/23,44%)和验证研究(66/84,79%)中最常见预测结局,时间窗各异,最常见为24小时。
- 最常见预测因子为呼吸频率(30/34,88%)、心率(28/34,83%)、氧饱和度、体温和收缩压(均24/34,71%)。
- 年龄(13/34,38%)和性别(3/34,9%)较少纳入。
- 分析人群关键细节在开发研究(12/29,41%)和验证研究(33/84,39%)中常未报告。
- 仅9个开发的预警评分报告足够细节以支持个体化风险预测;内部验证中仅4/19(22%)使用bootstrap或交叉验证。
临床怎么用
- 临床使用预警评分时应认识其方法学局限,不应过度依赖其预测性能。
- 优先选择报告充分、经过严格外部验证并评估校准度的评分工具。
局限性
- 仅纳入至2019年6月的文献,未覆盖此后发表的预警评分研究。
- 全部纳入研究评为高偏倚风险,结果解释需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To provide an overview and critical appraisal of early warning scores for adult hospital patients. DESIGN: Systematic review. DATA SOURCES: Medline, CINAHL, PsycInfo, and Embase until June 2019. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR STUDY SELECTION: Studies describing the development or external validation of an early warning score for adult hospital inpatients. RESULTS: 13 171 references were screened and 95 articles were included in the review. 11 studies were development only, 23 were development and external validation, and 61 were external validation only. Most early warning scores were developed for use in the United States (n=13/34, 38%) and the United Kingdom (n=10/34, 29%). Death was the most frequent prediction outcome for development studies (n=10/23, 44%) and validation studies (n=66/84, 79%), with different time horizons (the most frequent was 24 hours). The most common predictors were respiratory rate (n=30/34, 88%), heart rate (n=28/34, 83%), oxygen saturation, temperature, and systolic blood pressure (all n=24/34, 71%). Age (n=13/34, 38%) and sex (n=3/34, 9%) were less frequently included. Key details of the analysis populations were often not reported in development studies (n=12/29, 41%) or validation studies (n=33/84, 39%). Small sample sizes and insufficient numbers of event patients were common in model development and external validation studies. Missing data were often discarded, with just one study using multiple imputation. Only nine of the early warning scores that were developed were presented in sufficient detail to allow individualised risk prediction. Internal validation was carried out in 19 studies, but recommended approaches such as bootstrapping or cross validation were rarely used (n=4/19, 22%). Model performance was frequently assessed using discrimination (development n=18/22, 82%; validation n=69/84, 82%), while calibration was seldom assessed (validation n=13/84, 15%). All included studies were rated at high risk of bias. CONCLUSIONS: Early warning scores are widely used prediction models that are often mandated in daily clinical practice to identify early clinical deterioration in hospital patients. However, many early warning scores in clinical use were found to have methodological weaknesses. Early warning scores might not perform as well as expected and therefore they could have a detrimental effect on patient care. Future work should focus on following recommended approaches for developing and evaluating early warning scores, and investigating the impact and safety of using these scores in clinical practice. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42017053324.
引用
- Gerry S, Bonnici T, Birks J, et al. Early warning scores for detecting deterioration in adult hospital patients: systematic review and critical appraisal of methodology. BMJ. 2020. PMID: 32434791. doi:10.1136/bmj.m1501
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。