手术与功能支具治疗闭合移位肱骨干骨折的功能结局比较:FISH随机临床试验
该随机临床试验在芬兰2家大学医院创伤中心纳入82例成人闭合单侧移位肱骨干骨折患者,比较切开复位内固定手术与功能支具非手术治疗。12个月时手术组平均DASH评分为8.9,支具组为12.0,组间差异-3.1分(95%CI,-9.6至3.3;
要点
- 支具组30%患者随访期内因促进骨折愈合转为手术
- 支具组25%发生骨折不愈合,手术组8%出现暂时性桡神经麻痹
核心结论
- 在闭合性肱骨干骨折患者中,内固定手术与功能支具非手术治疗相比,未显著改善12个月功能结局。
- 解读结果时需考虑从非手术转向手术的大量治疗交叉。
研究设计与样本
- 共82例成人闭合单侧移位肱骨干骨折患者,随机分配至切开复位内固定手术组(n=38)或功能支具非手术组(n=44)。
- 排除存在妨碍遵循方案的认知障碍、多重疾病或多发创伤的患者。
- 78例(95%)完成试验;平均年龄48.9岁,女性38例(46%),男性44例(54%)。
主要发现
- 12个月时手术组平均DASH评分为8.9(95%CI,4.2至13.6),支具组为12.0(95%CI,7.7至16.4)。
- 分配至功能支具组的患者中13例(30%)在12个月随访期内接受手术以促进骨折愈合。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局为12个月时上肢功能障碍(DASH)评分,范围0至100分,0表示无功能障碍,100表示极度功能障碍。
- DASH评分的最小临床重要差异为10分。
临床怎么用
- 对于闭合移位肱骨干骨折,内固定手术在12个月功能结局上未优于功能支具,可支持非手术治疗的选用。
- 需告知患者功能支具治疗存在较高的转为手术比例(本试验为30%)及骨折不愈合风险(25%)。
- 手术组8%出现暂时性桡神经麻痹,决策时需权衡手术相关神经并发症。
局限性
- 样本量较小,共82例患者,可能不足以检出小到中等程度的组间差异。
- 支具组30%患者交叉接受手术,可能稀释意向性治疗分析中的组间差异。
- 排除认知障碍、多重疾病或多发创伤患者,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Humeral shaft fractures traditionally have been treated nonsurgically, but there has been a steady increase in the rate of surgery over the past 2 decades without high-quality evidence to justify the trend. OBJECTIVE: To compare the effectiveness of surgical treatment with open reduction and internal plate fixation to nonsurgical treatment with functional bracing in the treatment of closed humeral shaft fractures. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Randomized clinical trial conducted at 2 university hospital trauma centers in Finland, enrollment between November 2012 and January 2018 with a final follow-up of January 2019. A total of 82 adult patients with closed, unilateral, displaced humeral shaft fracture met criteria for inclusion. Patients were excluded if they had cognitive disabilities preventing them from following the protocol or had multimorbidity or multiple trauma. INTERVENTIONS: Patients were randomly assigned to surgical treatment with open reduction and internal plate fixation (n = 38) or to nonsurgical treatment with functional bracing (n = 44). MAIN OUTCOME AND MEASURE: The primary outcome was Disabilities of Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) score at 12 months (range, 0 to 100 points, 0 denotes no disability and 100 extreme disability; minimal clinically important difference, 10 points). RESULTS: Among 82 patients who were randomized (mean age, 48.9 years; 38 women [46%]; 44 men [54%]), 78 (95%) completed the trial. Thirteen (30%) of the patients assigned to functional bracing underwent surgery during the 12-month follow-up period to promote healing of the fracture. At 12 months, the mean DASH score was 8.9 (95% CI, 4.2 to 13.6) in the surgery group and 12.0 (95% CI, 7.7 to 16.4) in the bracing group (between-group difference, -3.1 points; 95% CI, -9.6 to 3.3; P = .34). Eleven patients (25%) allocated to functional bracing developed fracture nonunion. Three patients (8%) allocated to surgery developed a temporary radial nerve palsy. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Among patients with closed humeral shaft fracture, internal fixation surgery, compared with nonoperative functional bracing, did not significantly improve functional outcomes at 12 months. However, the substantial amount of treatment crossover from nonoperative to surgical treatment should be considered when interpreting the trial results. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01719887.
引用
- Rämö L, Sumrein BO, Lepola V, et al. Effect of Surgery vs Functional Bracing on Functional Outcome Among Patients With Closed Displaced Humeral Shaft Fractures: The FISH Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA. 2020. PMID: 32396179. doi:10.1001/jama.2020.3182
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。