核心结局集的争议与辩论:GRADE视角下的探讨
本文从GRADE视角探讨核心结局集在健康技术评估、质量保证、系统评价和指南等不同决策背景下的协调问题,提出中心-辐条模型和SOLAR系统方法,并引入健康结局描述符(HOD)作为解决方案,以促进结局评估的标准化和 harmonization。
要点
- 核心结局应关注对患者、家属和照护者最重要的结局。
- 中心-辐条模型支持不同学科和决策者之间的沟通与整合。
- 健康结局描述符(HOD)有助于协调不同决策背景下的结局评估。
核心结论
- 相关利益方应努力协调不同决策背景下的结局评估,并描述其所用结局与协调后的HOD的关系。
- 理想情况下,决策者应使用相同的协调HOD,并透明地评定实际结局的间接性程度。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为辩论类文章,从GRADE视角提出概念模型和方法,未涉及具体研究设计或样本。
主要发现
- 提出了中心-辐条模型用于直接核心结局集,并描述了SOLAR系统方法应对挑战和解决方案。
- GRADE的间接性域可用于判断决策者关注的结局与预期结局的对应程度。
- 健康结局描述符(HOD)为解决结局协调问题提供了方案。
临床怎么用
- 利益相关方应努力协调不同决策背景下的结局评估。
- 决策者应使用协调的HOD并透明评定实际结局的间接性程度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Outcome measures can be defined as the quality and cost targets health care organizations are trying to improve. Health-related outcomes are used to assess the effect, both positive and negative, of an intervention or treatment. To be meaningful and relevant, outcomes should ideally focus on what matters to the population to whom an intervention is applied and who may experience the outcomes. In this commentary, with a GRADE perspective in mind, we will introduce a conceptual model to address the many health care stakeholders, for example, in health technology assessment (HTA), quality assurance, systematic reviews, guidelines, and coverage decisions, who are involved in making different types of health decisions based on the same health outcomes. We will also propose and describe a method of defining core outcomes that will support reconciliation as well as harmonization across these different fields. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: The main focus here is on outcomes that matter most to people including patients, family members, and caregivers. We describe the hub and spokes model for core outcome sets that allows for communication and integration across different disciplines and decision makers. Ideally, the core outcomes, also called main outcomes, would be identical across these fields, including, for instance, a systematic review, an HTA, and a clinical or public health guideline. We illustrate this challenge using examples. RESULTS: We present the hub and spokes model for direct core outcome sets and describe the challenge and solution in what we call the Standardized Outcomes Linking Across StakeholdeRs (SOLAR) system approach. Judgments will have to be made regarding how directly the outcome of interest for decision makers corresponds to the intended outcome and GRADE offers it through its indirectness domain. Health outcome descriptors (HODs) provide a solution to this. CONCLUSION: Relevant stakeholders should strive to harmonize outcome assessment for the different decision-making contexts and describe how the outcomes they use, optimally informed by systematic reviews of the importance of outcomes, relate to harmonized HODs. In the ideal world, decision makers would use the same harmonized HODs and transparently rate the degree of indirectness of the actual outcomes addressed.
引用
- Schünemann HJ, Tunis S, Nieuwlaat R, et al. Controversy and Debate Series on Core Outcome Sets. Paper 3: Debate on Paper 1 from the perspective of GRADE [Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation]. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32438026. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.05.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。