STRATOS指南:观察性流行病学中变量测量误差与错分处理的复杂方法
本文是STRATOS指南第二部分,继续综述观察性流行病学中测量误差与错分问题,重点介绍连续协变量测量误差校正的似然法、贝叶斯法、矩重建、矩调整插补和多充插补,并讨论分类协变量错分、分布校正、联合模型、变量选择、结局误差及误差信息不足时的处理建议。
要点
- 连续协变量测量误差可用似然法、贝叶斯法、矩重建、矩调整插补和多充插补校正。
- 部分校正方法同样适用于分类协变量的错分。
- 误差类型或大小仅有外部参照或部分信息时,需谨慎处理并参考指南建议。
核心结论
- 针对观察性流行病学中测量误差与错分,本文系统介绍了多种复杂校正方法及高级主题,并给出误差信息不充分时的处理建议。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为方法学综述与指南,属于STRATOS指南第二部分,涵盖连续协变量测量误差校正、分类协变量错分校正、分布校正及高级主题,并附示例与软件列表。
主要发现
- 校正连续协变量测量误差的方法包括似然法、贝叶斯法、矩重建、矩调整插补和多充插补。
- 部分方法也可用于分类协变量的错分校正,并可用于连续变量分布的误差校正。
- 高级主题涵盖经典与伯克森误差并存、连续与分类暴露同时存在误差或错分、变量选择、结局变量误差校正及误差变量分类化。
临床怎么用
- 当已知变量存在实质性测量误差时,可依据本文方法选择校正策略,并参考所附软件和示例代码实现。
- 在仅有外部参照标准或部分误差信息时,可参考本文建议进行合理分析或设计调整。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
We continue our review of issues related to measurement error and misclassification in epidemiology. We further describe methods of adjusting for biased estimation caused by measurement error in continuous covariates, covering likelihood methods, Bayesian methods, moment reconstruction, moment-adjusted imputation, and multiple imputation. We then describe which methods can also be used with misclassification of categorical covariates. Methods of adjusting estimation of distributions of continuous variables for measurement error are then reviewed. Illustrative examples are provided throughout these sections. We provide lists of available software for implementing these methods and also provide the code for implementing our examples in the Supporting Information. Next, we present several advanced topics, including data subject to both classical and Berkson error, modeling continuous exposures with measurement error, and categorical exposures with misclassification in the same model, variable selection when some of the variables are measured with error, adjusting analyses or design for error in an outcome variable, and categorizing continuous variables measured with error. Finally, we provide some advice for the often met situations where variables are known to be measured with substantial error, but there is only an external reference standard or partial (or no) information about the type or magnitude of the error.
引用
- Shaw PA, Gustafson P, Carroll RJ, et al. STRATOS guidance document on measurement error and misclassification of variables in observational epidemiology: Part 2-More complex methods of adjustment and advanced topics. Stat Med. 2020. PMID: 32246531. doi:10.1002/sim.8531
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。