在线调查:STROBE声明内容、目的与价值观点分歧
该研究对观察性研究作者开展在线调查,对开放式问题的回答进行归纳编码主题分析。1015名参与者中150人(15%)分享了对STROBE声明的看法,形成四个主题:清单认知、学术信心、教育培训使用、期刊采纳与同行评审使用。观点多样,存在对清单目的与内容的多种误解及使用激励不足,呼吁加强传播沟通与激励执行机制。
要点
- STROBE声明在作者中存在多种误解,需加强内容传播与教育。
- 早期职业研究者应接受报告规范教育,并鼓励对自身工作批判性反思。
- 需建立更好的激励与执行机制以提高STROBE声明使用率。
核心结论
- 传播STROBE及其他报告指南时需加强沟通,聚焦内容、早期职业研究者教育及鼓励对自身工作的批判性反思。
- 结果强调需要更好的激励与执行机制。
研究设计与样本
- 对观察性研究作者开展在线调查,并对开放式问题的回答进行归纳编码主题分析。
- 两名编码者使用编码本独立将回答分类为主题,评分者间一致性范围为87.7%至99.9%。
主要发现
- 1015名调查参与者中150人(15%)分享了对STROBE声明的看法与见解。
- 确立四个主题:对清单的认知、学术信心、教育与培训中的使用、期刊采纳与同行评审中的使用。
- 观点多样,揭示了对清单目的与内容的多种误解及使用激励不足。
临床怎么用
- 在推广STROBE声明时加强内容沟通与早期职业研究者教育。
- 鼓励研究者对自身工作进行批判性自我反思。
- 建立更好的激励与执行机制以促进报告指南使用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: The endorsement rates of The STrengthening the Reporting of OBservational studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) Statement are low and little is known about authors' opinions about this reporting guideline. We conducted an online survey with observational study authors on attitude toward and experiences with the STROBE Statement with the aim of understanding how to effectively implement STROBE. METHODS: A thematic analysis on the responses to an open-ended question was conducted using inductive coding. Two coders classified responses independently into themes using a codebook. The inter-rater agreement ranged from 87.7 to 99.9%. RESULTS: 15% (n = 150) of survey participants (n = 1,015) shared perceptions and insights on STROBE. We established four themes: 1) perceptions of the checklist, 2) academic confidence, 3) use in education and training, and 4) journal endorsement and use in peer review. Views were diverse and revealed multiple misunderstandings about the checklist's purpose and content, and lack of incentives for its use. CONCLUSIONS: Better communication efforts are needed when disseminating STROBE and other reporting guidelines. These should focus on content, education for early career researchers, and encouragement of critical self-reflection on one's own work. In addition, results emphasized the need for better incentive and enforcement mechanisms.
引用
- Sharp MK, Glonti K, Hren D, et al. Online survey about the STROBE statement highlighted diverging views about its content, purpose, and value. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32259582. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.03.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。