Meta分析中排除双臂零事件研究会影响结论
该研究从Cochrane系统综述中收集442项至少含一个双臂零事件研究的二分类结局Meta分析,用广义线性混合模型比较纳入与排除这类研究的OR方向、P值和95%CI宽度,并通过模拟验证。结果显示排除后1.80%的Meta分析OR方向改变,9.28%的统计学显著性结论改变,P值和95%CI宽度也发生实质性变化。结论认为双臂零事件研究并非无信息,排除可能改变Meta分析结论。
要点
- 双臂零事件研究并非无信息,排除可能改变Meta分析结论。
- 排除后1.80%的Meta分析OR方向改变,9.28%的显著性结论改变。
- 排除后P值和95%CI宽度发生实质性变化,模拟研究验证了结果。
核心结论
- 双臂零事件研究不一定无信息,排除这类研究可能改变Meta分析结论。
研究设计与样本
- 从Cochrane系统综述(2003-2018)收集442项至少含一个双臂零事件研究的二分类结局Meta分析。
- 采用广义线性混合模型分别纳入与排除双臂零事件研究重新分析,比较OR方向、P值和95%CI宽度,并进行模拟研究验证稳健性。
主要发现
- 比较纳入与排除双臂零事件研究的配对Meta分析,8项(1.80%)OR方向不同。
- 41项(9.28%)统计学显著性结论改变。
- 排除后P值55.66%增大、44.12%减小;95%CI宽度50.68%增宽、49.32%变窄。
- 模拟研究证实了上述发现。
临床怎么用
- 在Meta分析中不应默认将双臂零事件研究视为无信息而排除,应评估其对结论的潜在影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Classical meta-analyses routinely treated studies with no events in both arms noninformative and excluded them from analyses. This study assessed whether such studies contain information and have an influence on the conclusions of meta-analyses. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We collected meta-analyses of binary outcomes with at least one study having no events in both arms from Cochrane systematic reviews (2003-2018). We used the generalized linear mixed model to reanalyze these meta-analyses by two approaches: one including studies with no events in both arms and one excluding such studies. The magnitude and direction of odds ratio (OR), P value, and width of 95% confidence interval (CI) were compared. A simulation study was conducted to examine the robustness of results. RESULTS: We identified 442 meta-analyses. In comparing paired meta-analyses that included studies with no events in both arms vs. those not, 8 (1.80%) resulted in different directions on OR; 41 (9.28%) altered conclusions on statistical significance. Substantial changes occurred on P value (55.66% increased and 44.12% decreased) and the width of 95% CI (50.68% inflated and 49.32% declined) when excluding studies with no events. Simulation study confirmed these findings. CONCLUSION: Studies with no events in both arms are not necessarily noninformative. Excluding such studies may alter conclusions.
引用
- Xu C, Li L, Lin L, et al. Exclusion of studies with no events in both arms in meta-analysis impacted the conclusions. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32247025. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.03.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。