网络荟萃分析中多数信息来自间接证据:一项实证研究
该研究分析213篇已发表的网络荟萃分析(NMA),基于贡献矩阵计算不同长度网络路径对效应估计的贡献百分比。结果显示33%信息来自长度1路径(直接证据),47%来自长度2路径,20%来自长度3路径;路径贡献取决于网络大小、闭环存在及图半径、密度和直径。
要点
- NMA中仅33%信息来自直接证据,47%来自一个中间治疗的间接路径。
- 较长路径的贡献随治疗数量、闭环数及图半径和直径增加而增大。
- 评估NMA偏倚风险与置信度时需考虑网络大小和结构。
核心结论
- 不同长度路径的贡献取决于网络大小和结构,对评估NMA结果的偏倚风险和置信度有重要影响。
研究设计与样本
- 实证研究分析213篇已发表的网络荟萃分析(NMA)。
- 按是否存在至少一个闭环将网络分为非星形或星形网络,并推导图密度、半径和直径。
- 基于贡献矩阵识别不同长度路径并计算其对每个NMA效应估计的贡献百分比。
主要发现
- 213篇NMA中,33%的信息来自长度1路径(直接证据)。
- 47%的信息来自长度2路径(含一个中间治疗的间接路径)。
- 20%的信息来自长度3路径。
- 不同长度路径的贡献取决于网络大小、闭环存在以及图半径、密度和直径。
- 随着治疗数量、闭环数以及图半径和直径增加,较长路径贡献更多。
临床怎么用
- 在解读NMA结果时,应关注网络大小和结构对间接证据贡献的影响。
- 评估NMA偏倚风险和置信度时需考虑不同长度路径的贡献比例。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Network meta-analysis (NMA) may produce more precise estimates of treatment effects than pairwise meta-analysis. We examined the relative contribution of network paths of different lengths to estimates of treatment effects. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We analyzed 213 published NMAs. We categorized network shapes according to the presence or absence of at least one closed loop (nonstar or star network) and derived the graph density, radius, and diameter. We identified paths of different lengths and calculated their percentage contribution to each NMA effect estimate, based on their contribution matrix. RESULTS: Among the 213 NMAs included in analyses, 33% of the information came from paths of length 1 (direct evidence), 47% from paths of length 2 (indirect paths with one intermediate treatment) and 20% from paths of length 3. The contribution of paths of different lengths depended on the size of networks, presence of closed loops, and graph radius, density, and diameter. Longer paths contribute more as the number of treatments and loops and the graph radius and diameter increase. CONCLUSION: The contribution of different paths depends on the size and structure of networks, with important implications for assessing the risk of bias and confidence in NMA results.
引用
- Papakonstantinou T, Nikolakopoulou A, Egger M, et al. In network meta-analysis, most of the information comes from indirect evidence: empirical study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32302680. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.04.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。