14种流行饮食方案对减重及心血管危险因素影响的系统综述与网状Meta分析
该研究通过系统综述与网状Meta分析比较了14种流行饮食方案及三种对照饮食对超重或肥胖成人减重和心血管危险因素的影响。
要点
- 低碳水与低脂饮食6个月减重和降压效果相似,中等确定性证据。
- 低碳水饮食对LDL胆固醇降低作用较小,但可升高HDL胆固醇。
- Atkins、DASH和Zone饮食在6个月时减重和降压效果最显著。
核心结论
- 中等确定性证据表明多数宏量营养素饮食在6个月内可适度减重并显著改善心血管危险因素,尤其是血压。
- 12个月时减重和心血管危险因素改善效果基本消失。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与随机试验的网状Meta分析,检索Medline、Embase、CINAHL、AMED和CENTRAL至2018年9月。
主要发现
- 与常规饮食相比,低碳水和低脂饮食6个月减重分别为4.63 kg和4.37 kg(中等确定性)。
- 低碳水和低脂饮食6个月收缩压降低分别为5.14 mmHg和5.05 mmHg,舒张压降低分别为3.21 mmHg和2.85 mmHg。
- 低碳水饮食降低LDL胆固醇1.01 mg/dL(低确定性),低脂饮食降低7.08 mg/dL(中等确定性),中等宏量营养素饮食降低5.22 mg/dL(中等确定性)。
- 低碳水饮食升高HDL胆固醇2.31 mg/dL(低确定性),低脂饮食降低1.88 mg/dL(中等确定性),中等宏量营养素饮食降低0.89 mg/dL(中等确定性)。
- 6个月时减重和降压效果最大的命名饮食为Atkins(减重5.5 kg,收缩压降5.1 mmHg,舒张压降3.3 mmHg)、DASH(3.6 kg,4.7 mmHg,2.9 mmHg)和Zone(4.1 kg,3.5 mmHg,2.3 mmHg),均为中等确定性。
关键数值与推荐
- 超重定义为BMI 25-29,肥胖定义为BMI≥30。
- 6个月时低碳水与低脂饮食减重效果相似(4.63 kg vs 4.37 kg,中等确定性)。
- 12个月时所有宏量营养素模式和命名饮食的减重效果均减弱,除地中海饮食外其他干预的心血管危险因素改善基本消失。
临床怎么用
- 临床可选择低碳水或低脂饮食帮助超重或肥胖成人短期减重和改善血压。
- 需告知患者饮食干预的减重和心血管获益在12个月时可能减弱或消失。
- 地中海饮食可能具有较持久的心血管危险因素改善效果。
局限性
- 原始研究间存在异质性,部分结局证据确定性较低。
- 12个月随访数据有限,长期效果不确定。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the relative effectiveness of dietary macronutrient patterns and popular named diet programmes for weight loss and cardiovascular risk factor improvement among adults who are overweight or obese. DESIGN: Systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised trials. DATA SOURCES: Medline, Embase, CINAHL, AMED, and CENTRAL from database inception until September 2018, reference lists of eligible trials, and related reviews. STUDY SELECTION: Randomised trials that enrolled adults (≥18 years) who were overweight (body mass index 25-29) or obese (≥30) to a popular named diet or an alternative diet. OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Change in body weight, low density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol, high density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood pressure, and C reactive protein at the six and 12 month follow-up. REVIEW METHODS: Two reviewers independently extracted data on study participants, interventions, and outcomes and assessed risk of bias, and the certainty of evidence using the GRADE (grading of recommendations, assessment, development, and evaluation) approach. A bayesian framework informed a series of random effects network meta-analyses to estimate the relative effectiveness of the diets. RESULTS: 121 eligible trials with 21 942 patients were included and reported on 14 named diets and three control diets. Compared with usual diet, low carbohydrate and low fat diets had a similar effect at six months on weight loss (4.63 v 4.37 kg, both moderate certainty) and reduction in systolic blood pressure (5.14 mm Hg, moderate certainty v 5.05 mm Hg, low certainty) and diastolic blood pressure (3.21 v 2.85 mm Hg, both low certainty). Moderate macronutrient diets resulted in slightly less weight loss and blood pressure reductions. Low carbohydrate diets had less effect than low fat diets and moderate macronutrient diets on reduction in LDL cholesterol (1.01 mg/dL, low certainty v 7.08 mg/dL, moderate certainty v 5.22 mg/dL, moderate certainty, respectively) but an increase in HDL cholesterol (2.31 mg/dL, low certainty), whereas low fat (-1.88 mg/dL, moderate certainty) and moderate macronutrient (-0.89 mg/dL, moderate certainty) did not. Among popular named diets, those with the largest effect on weight reduction and blood pressure in comparison with usual diet were Atkins (weight 5.5 kg, systolic blood pressure 5.1 mm Hg, diastolic blood pressure 3.3 mm Hg), DASH (3.6 kg, 4.7 mm Hg, 2.9 mm Hg, respectively), and Zone (4.1 kg, 3.5 mm Hg, 2.3 mm Hg, respectively) at six months (all moderate certainty). No diets significantly improved levels of HDL cholesterol or C reactive protein at six months. Overall, weight loss diminished at 12 months among all macronutrient patterns and popular named diets, while the benefits for cardiovascular risk factors of all interventions, except the Mediterranean diet, essentially disappeared. CONCLUSIONS: Moderate certainty evidence shows that most macronutrient diets, over six months, result in modest weight loss and substantial improvements in cardiovascular risk factors, particularly blood pressure. At 12 months the effects on weight reduction and improvements in cardiovascular risk factors largely disappear. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42015027929.
引用
- Ge L, Sadeghirad B, Ball GDC, et al. Comparison of dietary macronutrient patterns of 14 popular named dietary programmes for weight and cardiovascular risk factor reduction in adults: systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised trials. BMJ. 2020. PMID: 32238384. doi:10.1136/bmj.m696
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。