临床试验招募预测模型在英国与欧洲网络中鲜为统计师所用
该研究调查英国与欧洲临床试验网络的主要研究者(CI)和统计师,了解招募预测与监测的现行做法。结果显示简单预测方法更受青睐,统计模型极少使用,不熟悉统计方法是主要障碍;相当一部分受访者感到需对招募率保持乐观以吸引资助。
要点
- 招募预测以简单方法为主,复杂统计模型极少使用。
- 多数据源支持招募率估计,最常用多中心审计数据。
- 不熟悉统计方法是统计模型应用的主要障碍。
核心结论
- 简单方法将继续作为招募预测的主流,需生成证据支持复杂统计模型的获益以促进其应用。
研究设计与样本
- 对主要研究者与统计师进行问卷调查,参与者来自英国国家卫生研究院近期资助研究、英国临床试验单位网络或欧洲临床试验基础设施网络。
主要发现
- 共联系51名主要研究者(英国32名,ECRIN 19名)和104名统计师(英国51名,ECRIN 53名)。
- 答复率不一:主要研究者英国53%、ECRIN 32%;统计师英国98%、ECRIN 36%。
- 多数据源用于支持招募率,最常用多中心审计数据,个体中心招募率变异常被纳入。
- 英国受访者更常纳入中心 staggered 开放( staggered site openings)。
- 简单预测方法优于极少使用的统计模型,不熟悉统计方法是障碍。
临床怎么用
- 招募预测可优先采用简单方法并整合多中心审计数据。
- 纳入个体中心招募率变异及中心开放时间差异以提高预测合理性。
局限性
- 答复率存在差异,尤其ECRIN主要研究者和统计师答复率较低。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Identify the current practice for recruitment prediction and monitoring within clinical trials. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Chief investigators (CIs) were surveyed to identify data sources and adjustments made to support recruitment prediction. Statisticians were surveyed to determine methods and adjustments used when predicting and monitoring recruitment. Participants were identified from the National Institute for Health Research recently funded studies, the UK Clinical Research Collaboration registered Clinical Trial Units network or by the European Clinical Research Infrastructure Network. RESULTS: A total of 51 CIs (UK = 32, ECRIN = 19) and 104 statisticians (UK = 51, ECRIN = 53) were contacted. Response rates varied (CIs UK = 53% ECRIN = 32%; statisticians UK = 98% ECRIN = 36%). Multiple data sources are used to support recruitment rates, most commonly audit data from multiple sites. Variation in individual site recruitment rates are frequently incorporated, but staggered site openings were featured more commonly among UK respondents. Simple prediction methods are preferred to rarely used statistical models. Lack of familiarity with statistical methods are barriers to their use with evidence needed to justify the time required to support their implementation. CONCLUSION: Simplistic methods will continue as the mainstay of prediction; however, generation of evidence supporting the benefits of complex statistical models should promote their implementations. Multiple data sources to support recruitment prediction are being used, and further work on the quality of these data is needed. Pressure to be optimistic about recruitment rates for the trial to be attractive to funders was felt by a sizable minority.
引用
- Gkioni E, Dodd S, Rius R, et al. Statistical models to predict recruitment in clinical trials were rarely used by statisticians in UK and European networks. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32229249. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.03.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。