数字工具在随机对照试验招募与保留中的应用调查
该英国国家卫生研究院研究通过调查全英52个临床试验单位(CTU)及16次定性访谈,识别随机对照试验中数字工具的使用现状与性能需求。24个CTU(46%)回复显示数据库筛选工具最常用于招募且多被认为有效,保留工具使用较少,短信或邮件提醒最常见。访谈归纳出安全透明、包容参与、人际互动、障碍风险与潜在获益五大主题,利益相关者接受度高但缺乏高质量证据支持。
要点
- 数据库筛选工具是CTU最常用的招募数字工具,多数被认为有效。
- 保留类数字工具使用较少,短信或邮件提醒最常被报告。
- 利益相关者接受数字工具但缺乏高质量证据支持其优于传统方法。
核心结论
- 研究识别了RCT招募与保留中使用的多种数字工具,但缺乏高质量证据支持其使用。
- 了解在用数字工具类型有助于资助方和科研社区评估其价值与相关性。
研究设计与样本
- 范围检索、对NIHR资助人员的调查、对全部52个UKCRC CTU的调查及16次定性访谈。
- 定性访谈于2018年3月至6月采用目的抽样,覆盖试验人员、资助方和研究参与者等五类利益相关群体。
- 定性数据采用内容分析和归纳法分析。
主要发现
- 24个CTU(46%)回复调查,数据库筛选工具是最广泛使用的招募数字工具,多数被认为有效。
- 数据库筛选工具被认为有效的原因在于识别潜在参与者(对站点和CTU人员)及达成招募目标(对CTU人员/主要研究者)。
- 保留工具使用较少,向参与者发送短信或邮件提醒是最常报告的方式。
- 定性访谈归纳出五大主题:安全与透明、包容与参与、人际互动、障碍与风险、潜在获益。
- 尽管缺乏证据支持数字工具优于传统技术,利益相关者对其用于支持试验的接受度较高。
临床怎么用
- CTU可参考数据库筛选工具用于识别潜在参与者并辅助达成招募目标。
- 保留环节可考虑短信或邮件提醒,但需注意证据基础尚不充分。
- 资助方和科研社区可依据在用数字工具类型评估其对未来RCT的价值与相关性。
局限性
- CTU调查回复率为46%(24/52),可能存在应答偏倚。
- 缺乏高质量证据支持数字工具优于传统招募与保留技术。
- 定性访谈采用目的抽样,结果可能受样本选择影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recruitment and retention of participants in randomised controlled trials (RCTs) is a key determinant of success but is challenging. Trialists and UK Clinical Research Collaboration (UKCRC) Clinical Trials Units (CTUs) are increasingly exploring the use of digital tools to identify, recruit and retain participants. The aim of this UK National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) study was to identify what digital tools are currently used by CTUs and understand the performance characteristics required to be judged useful. METHODS: A scoping of searches (and a survey with NIHR funding staff), a survey with all 52 UKCRC CTUs and 16 qualitative interviews were conducted with five stakeholder groups including trialists within CTUs, funders and research participants. A purposive sampling approach was used to conduct the qualitative interviews during March-June 2018. Qualitative data were analysed using a content analysis and inductive approach. RESULTS: Responses from 24 (46%) CTUs identified that database-screening tools were the most widely used digital tool for recruitment, with the majority being considered effective. The reason (and to whom) these tools were considered effective was in identifying potential participants (for both Site staff and CTU staff) and reaching recruitment target (for CTU staff/CI). Fewer retention tools were used, with short message service (SMS) or email reminders to participants being the most reported. The qualitative interviews revealed five themes across all groups: 'security and transparency'; 'inclusivity and engagement'; 'human interaction'; 'obstacles and risks'; and 'potential benefits'. There was a high level of stakeholder acceptance of the use of digital tools to support trials, despite the lack of evidence to support them over more traditional techniques. Certain differences and similarities between stakeholder groups demonstrated the complexity and challenges of using digital tools for recruiting and retaining research participants. CONCLUSIONS: Our studies identified a range of digital tools in use in recruitment and retention of RCTs, despite the lack of high-quality evidence to support their use. Understanding the type of digital tools in use to support recruitment and retention will help to inform funders and the wider research community about their value and relevance for future RCTs. Consideration of further focused digital tool reviews and primary research will help to reduce gaps in the evidence base.
引用
- Blatch-Jones A, Nuttall J, Bull A, et al. Using digital tools in the recruitment and retention in randomised controlled trials: survey of UK Clinical Trial Units and a qualitative study. Trials. 2020. PMID: 32245506. doi:10.1186/s13063-020-04234-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。