患者为何参与研究:心理社会障碍与促进因素的系统综述概览
该概览纳入26篇系统综述(含429项原始研究),系统识别影响研究参与的心理社会因素,并将其映射至心理学理论框架与实证招募研究。研究发现三类跨情境的促进因素(个人获益可能、利他主义、信任)和九类更依赖具体研究情境的障碍,部分因素兼具障碍与促进双重作用。结论提示识别有效招募策略可提升原始研究的效率与可推广性。
要点
- 个人获益可能、利他主义与信任是跨研究情境的核心参与促进因素。
- 障碍因素更依赖具体研究的情境、人群与设计,共归纳为九类。
- 部分心理社会因素尚未在实证招募研究中被检验,需进一步研究。
核心结论
- 识别有效的招募策略可提高原始研究的效率与可推广性。
- 研究者可针对已识别的心理社会障碍与促进因素设计干预。
- 仍需更多研究验证基于这些因素的有效招募策略。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述概览,系统检索定性与定量系统综述,无日期或语言限制。
- 两名评审独立筛选综述,采用AMSTAR评价方法学质量,排除评分0-3的差质量综述。
- 共纳入26篇系统综述,覆盖429项唯一原始研究,涵盖广泛患者人群与卫生场景。
主要发现
- 识别出五组促进因素,其中个人获益可能、利他主义、信任三组为主导且似跨研究场景与设计相关。
- 识别出九组障碍因素,更依赖具体研究的情境、人群与设计。
- 参与者信息与社会影响两项因素同时被归为障碍与促进因素。
- 障碍与促进因素可编码至理论域框架的动机与机会成分,仅一项编码至能力成分。
- 心理社会因素与实证招募研究存在部分重叠,但部分障碍与促进因素完全未被检验。
临床怎么用
- 招募设计可优先关注个人获益可能、利他主义与信任等跨情境促进因素。
- 针对具体研究情境识别并应对相应的障碍因素。
- 可利用理论域框架的动机与机会成分指导招募策略制定。
局限性
- 部分障碍与促进因素尚未在实证招募研究中被检验。
- 障碍因素更依赖具体研究情境,跨研究推广需谨慎。
- 仅一项因素可编码至理论域框架的能力成分。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Understanding why people take part in health research is critical to improve research efficiency and generalisability. The aim of this overview of systematic reviews was to identify psychosocial determinants of research participation and map them to psychological theory and empirical recruitment research, to identify effective strategies to increase research participation. METHODS: Qualitative and quantitative systematic reviews were systematically identified. No date or language limits were applied. Two reviewers independently selected reviews. Methodological quality was rated using AMSTAR, and poor-quality reviews (scoring 0-3) were excluded. Barriers and facilitators were coded to psychological theory (Theoretical Domains Framework) and empirical recruitment research (recruitment interventions that had been subjected to randomised controlled trial evaluation). RESULTS: We included 26 systematic reviews (429 unique primary studies), covering a wide range of patient populations and health settings. We identified five groups of facilitators, of which three were dominant (potential for personal benefit, altruism, trust) and appear to be relevant across research setting and design. We identified nine groups of barriers, which were more dependent on the particular study (context, population, design). Two determinants (participant information, social influences) were found to be both barriers and facilitators. Barriers and facilitators could be coded to the Motivation and Opportunity components of the Theoretical Domains Framework; only one was coded to a Capability component. There was some overlap between psychosocial determinants and empirical recruitment research, but some barriers and facilitators had not been tested at all. CONCLUSIONS: Identifying effective recruitment strategies could increase the efficiency and generalisability of primary research. We identified a number of barriers and facilitators that could be addressed by researchers. There is a need for more research to identify effective recruitment strategies that draw on the psychosocial facilitators and barriers identified in this overview.
引用
- Sheridan R, Martin-Kerry J, Hudson J, et al. Why do patients take part in research? An overview of systematic reviews of psychosocial barriers and facilitators. Trials. 2020. PMID: 32164790. doi:10.1186/s13063-020-4197-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。