荟萃流行病学争议:随机试验疗效估计因结局测量类型而异
该研究比较物理治疗随机试验中患者报告结局(PROM)与其他类型结局的疗效估计差异。纳入90篇Cochrane系统评价中的205项试验,发现总体比值比比值(ROR)无统计学意义(ROR 0.88,95%CI 0.70-1.12,P=0.30),但异质性大(I2=88.1%);PROM与明确客观非PROM相比效应更有利(ROR 1.92,95%CI 0.99-3.72,P=0.05)。
要点
- PROM与其他非PROM的疗效估计总体可比。
- PROM与明确客观非PROM相比可能显示更有利效应。
- 不同结局类型间异质性显著,解读需谨慎。
核心结论
- 基于PROM的疗效估计与其他方式测量的疗效总体相当。
- 但PROM相较于明确客观非PROM可能显示更有利的疗效。
研究设计与样本
- 从Cochrane系统评价中筛选同时包含PROM和非PROM的物理治疗随机试验,由两名评价者独立提取数据并评估偏倚风险。
- 共纳入90篇相关Cochrane系统评价中的205项物理治疗随机试验。
主要发现
- 所有比较的汇总ROR无统计学意义(ROR 0.88,95%CI 0.70-1.12,P=0.30),但异质性较大(I2=88.1%)。
- PROM与明确客观非PROM相比,效应更有利于PROM(ROR 1.92,95%CI 0.99-3.72,P=0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- ROR>1表示PROM评估的效应更大;总体ROR=0.88(95%CI 0.70-1.12,P=0.30)。
- PROM vs 明确客观非PROM:ROR=1.92(95%CI 0.99-3.72,P=0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 在解读物理治疗试验时,应考虑结局测量类型对效应估计的潜在影响。
- PROM与客观结局的疗效差异需结合具体临床情境谨慎解释。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare estimated treatment effects of physical therapy (PT) between patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) and outcomes measured in other ways. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We selected randomized trials of PT with both a PROM and a non-PROM included in Cochrane systematic reviews (CSRs). Two reviewers independently extracted data and risk-of-bias assessments. Our primary outcome was the ratio of odds ratios (RORs), used to quantify how effect varies between PROMs and non-PROMs; an ROR > 1 indicates larger effect when assessed by using PROMs. We used REML-methods to estimate associations of trial characteristics with effects and between-trial heterogeneity. RESULTS: From 90 relevant CSRs, 205 PT trials were included. The summary ROR across all the comparisons was not statistically significant (ROR, 0.88 [95% CI: 0.70-1.12]; P = 0.30); however, the heterogeneity was substantial (I2 = 88.1%). When stratifying non-PROMs further into clearly objective non-PROMs (e.g., biomarkers) and other non-PROMs (e.g., aerobic capacity), the PROMs appeared more favorable than did clearly objective non-PROMs (ROR, 1.92 [95% CI: 0.99-3.72]; P = 0.05). CONCLUSION: Estimated treatment effects based on PROMs are generally comparable with treatment effects measured in other ways. However, in our study, PROMs indicate a more favorable treatment effect compared with treatment effects based on clearly objective outcomes.
引用
- Berthelsen DB, Ginnerup-Nielsen E, Juhl C, et al. Controversy and Debate on Meta-epidemiology. Paper 1: Treatment effect sizes vary in randomized trials depending on the type of outcome measure. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32217079. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.10.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。