证据生态系统未来系列一:证据合成生态系统亟需重大变革
本文概述了治疗性干预系统评价与Meta分析在规划、实施和报告方面的不足,指出当前证据合成生态系统未能满足利益相关者需求,且受原始研究质量与选择性报告影响。作者认为需进行重大变革,使未来证据生态系统以用户需求为导向并更好服务于决策。
要点
- 当前治疗性干预系统评价与Meta分析的生产过程规划不稳定且不全面,易产生偏倚。
- 证据合成依赖原始研究质量,原始研究不可得、有偏倚或选择性报告会带来重要问题。
- 原始研究生产者与系统评价者之间缺乏互动,阻碍数据的最优利用。
核心结论
- 需要进行重大变革,使未来证据生态系统以用户驱动和用户为导向,并对决策更有用。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为对当前治疗性干预证据合成系统局限性的概述。
主要发现
- 尽管治疗性干预系统评价发表数量不断增加,当前证据合成生态系统仍未恰当满足利益相关者需求。
- 当前生产过程因规划不稳定且低效,导致产生一系列分散的系统评价,过程并不总是全面且易产生偏倚。
- 证据合成依赖原始研究质量,原始研究不可得、有偏倚或选择性报告会带来重要问题。
- 原始研究生产者群体与系统评价者之间缺乏互动,阻碍数据的最优利用。
- 研究创新、终结一刀切方法的新医学模式、更多可用数据及新的患者期望等背景已发生显著变化,需引入未来证据生态系统。
临床怎么用
- 未来证据生态系统的构建应以用户驱动和用户为导向,以更好服务于决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This article presents why the planning, conduct, and reporting of systematic reviews and meta-analyses of therapeutic interventions are suboptimal. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We present an overview of the limitations of the current system of evidence synthesis for therapeutic interventions. RESULTS: Systematic reviews and meta-analyses are a cornerstone of health care decisions. However, despite the increasing a number of published systematic reviews of therapeutic interventions, the current evidence synthesis ecosystem is not properly addressing stakeholders' needs. The current production process leads to a series of disparate systematic reviews because of erratic and inefficient planning with a process that is not always comprehensive and is prone to bias. Evidence synthesis depends on the quality of primary research, so primary research that is not available is biased or selectively reported raises important concerns. Moreover, the lack of interactions between the community of primary research producers and systematic reviewers impedes the optimal use of data. The context has considerably evolved, with ongoing research innovations, a new medical approach with the end of the one-size-fits-all approach, more available data, and new patient expectations. All these changes must be introduced into the future evidence ecosystem. CONCLUSION: Dramatic changes are needed to enable this future ecosystem to become user driven and user oriented and more useful for decision-making.
引用
- Boutron I, Créquit P, Williams H, et al. Future of evidence ecosystem series: 1. Introduction Evidence synthesis ecosystem needs dramatic change. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32145367. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.01.024
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。