系统综述作者对将方案作为同行评议文章发表的看法不一致:一项国际调查
该调查邀请2018年注册于PROSPERO的非Cochrane系统综述联系人参会,回收4223份(33.7%),其中3739份完整。近半数受访者已发表或计划发表方案,多数认为同行评议发表提升质量,但64.2%认为注册于PROSPERO已足够,显示观点不一致。
要点
- 近半数系统综述作者已发表或计划发表研究方案。
- 77.5%认为同行评议发表方案可提升系统综述质量。
- 64.2%认为注册于PROSPERO已足够,无需同行评议发表。
核心结论
- 系统综述作者对将方案作为同行评议文章发表的看法不一致,许多人认为仅注册于PROSPERO已足够。
- 建议提高对同行评议发表方案额外益处的认识。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为匿名在线调查(5分钟,通过SurveyMonkey),对象为2018年注册于PROSPERO的非Cochrane系统综述联系人参会,共邀请12531人。
主要发现
- 4223/12531(33.7%)受邀者回应,其中3739/4223(88.5%)完成调查。
- 1811/4054(44.7%)受访者已发表或计划发表其PROSPERO记录对应的系统综述方案作为同行评议文章。
- 2899/3739(77.5%)受访者同意同行评议发表方案通过外部反馈提升系统综述质量。
- 2399/3739(64.2%)受访者同意若系统综述已注册于PROSPERO则无需同行评议发表方案。
临床怎么用
- 临床研究者应认识到同行评议发表系统综述方案可能提升质量,但需与PROSPERO注册的充分性权衡。
- 在决定是否发表方案时,可参考同行反馈对方案透明度和方法学的潜在改进。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to explore views of authors of systematic reviews (SRs) registered in the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) toward publishing SR protocols as peer-reviewed articles. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Contact persons of all PROSPERO records for non-Cochrane SRs registered in 2018 (N = 12,531) were invited to participate in an anonymous 5-minute online survey that was administered through SurveyMonkey. The main question addressed SR authors' views toward publishing SR protocols as peer-reviewed articles. Data were analyzed descriptively. RESULTS: In total, 4,223 (33.7%) of 12,531 invitees responded, of which 3,739 (88.5%) completed the survey. Almost half of the international respondents had published or planned to publish a protocol for the SR described in their PROSPERO record as a peer-reviewed article (1,811/4,054; 44.7%). Most respondents agreed that publishing a protocol in a peer-reviewed journal increases SR quality as reviewers get external feedback from peer reviewers (2,899/3,739; 77.5%) but at the same time agreed that it is not necessary if the SR is registered in PROSPERO (2,399/3,739; 64.2%). CONCLUSION: SR authors seem to have inconsistent views toward publishing protocols as peer-reviewed articles, and many seem to consider registration in PROSPERO (without peer review) sufficient. Hence, awareness about the benefits of publishing protocols as a peer-reviewed article in addition to registration in PROSPERO should be raised.
引用
- Rombey T, Puljak L, Allers K, et al. Inconsistent views among systematic review authors toward publishing protocols as peer-reviewed articles: an international survey. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32201257. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.03.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。