人口流动性对病例对照研究中环境暴露效应估计的影响
该研究通过模拟分析评估了在病例对照研究中忽略人口流动性对长潜伏期疾病环境暴露效应估计的偏倚影响,使用美国国立卫生研究院-AARP饮食与健康研究随机样本的居住历史模拟病例对照状态,发现忽略人口流动性会导致暴露低估,且暴露的时空变异性越大、时间点距入组越远,偏倚越明显。
要点
- 忽略人口流动性会低估环境暴露,时间点距入组越远偏差越大。
- 暴露的时空变异性越大,人口流动性对效应估计的偏倚影响越突出。
- 当环境暴露与疾病潜伏期跨度较长时,建议使用居住历史。
核心结论
- 在病例对照研究中,忽略人口流动性会导致环境暴露低估,并对暴露与结局关系的效应估计产生偏倚,尤其对于时空变异性大的暴露和距离入组较远的时间点。
- 建议当环境暴露与疾病潜伏期跨度足够长、流动性重要时,使用居住历史进行评估。
研究设计与样本
- 模拟研究,使用美国国立卫生研究院-AARP饮食与健康研究随机样本的居住历史。
- 基于受试者暴露和随时间变化的真实暴露效应模拟病例对照状态。
- 比较仅使用诊断时位置模型与假设受试者移动模型的估计。
主要发现
- 忽略人口流动性导致受试者暴露低估,最大偏差出现在距离研究入组较远的时间点。
- 人口流动性对暴露与结局关系估计偏倚的影响在暴露具有显著时空变异性时更突出。
临床怎么用
- 在环境暴露与长潜伏期疾病的病例对照研究中,应考虑使用居住历史而非仅诊断时位置。
- 当暴露时空变异性大且研究时间跨度长时,忽略人口流动性可能引入偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In many studies of environmental risk factors for disease, researchers use the location at diagnosis as a geographic reference for environmental exposures. However, many environmental pollutants change continuously over space and time. The dynamic characteristics of these pollutants coupled with population mobility in the United States suggest that for diseases with long latencies like cancer, historic exposures may be more relevant than exposure at the time of diagnosis. In this article, we evaluated to what extent the commonly used assumption of no population mobility results in increased bias in the estimates of the relationship between environmental exposures and long-latency health outcomes disease in a case-control study. We conducted a simulation study using the residential histories of a random sample from the National Institutes of Health-AARP (formerly American Association of Retired Persons) Diet and Health Study. We simulated case-control status based on subject exposure and true exposure effects that varied temporally. We compared estimates from models using only subject location at diagnosis to estimates where subjects were assumed to be mobile. Ignoring population mobility resulted in underestimates of subject exposure, with largest deviations observed at time points further away from study enrollment. In general, the effect of population mobility on the bias of the estimates of the relationship between the exposure and the outcome was more prominent with exposures that showed substantial spatial and temporal variability. Based on our results, we recommend using residential histories when environmental exposures and disease latencies span a long enough time period that mobility is important.
引用
- Joseph AC, Fuentes M, Wheeler DC, et al. The impact of population mobility on estimates of environmental exposure effects in a case-control study. Stat Med. 2020. PMID: 32059071. doi:10.1002/sim.8501
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。