使用自动化工具在两周内完成完整系统评价:案例研究
该案例研究描述了一个由经验丰富的系统评价员组成的小团队,使用系统评价自动化工具并保障专注时间,在2周内完成了关于增加液体摄入对尿路感染复发影响的系统评价。结果显示,系统评价在61人时(9个工作日;12个日历日)内完成,被接收版本稿件需要71人时;最耗时的任务为数据提取、撰写、摘要筛选、全文筛选和偏倚风险评估。
要点
- 使用自动化工具和经验丰富的团队可在2周内完成中等规模系统评价。
- 数据提取和撰写是最耗时的系统评价任务。
- 保障专注时间和团队互补技能是促进系统评价快速完成的关键因素。
核心结论
- 由经验丰富的系统评价员组成的小团队,使用系统评价自动化工具并有保障时间专注于系统评价,可在2周内完成中等规模的系统评价。
研究设计与样本
- 案例研究:系统评价增加液体摄入对尿路感染复发的影响,由两名临床研究者、一名信息专家和一名流行病学家使用系统评价自动化工具完成,并记录完成时间和反馈。
主要发现
- 系统评价在61人时(9个工作日;12个日历日)内完成,被接收版本稿件需要71人时。
- 单项任务耗时从16人分钟(去重)到461人分钟(数据提取)不等。
- 最耗时的任务为数据提取、撰写、摘要筛选、全文筛选和偏倚风险评估。
- 促进和障碍因素映射到知识、技能、记忆注意和决策过程、环境背景和资源、技术和基础设施等领域。
- 收到两轮同行评审反馈:第一轮34条评论要求修改,17条修改,耗时173人分钟;第二轮13条修改,8条修改,耗时121人分钟。
临床怎么用
- 对于中等规模系统评价,可考虑组建经验丰富、技能互补的小团队,使用系统评价自动化工具,并保障专注时间以加速完成。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Systematic reviews (SRs) are time and resource intensive, requiring approximately 1 year from protocol registration to submission for publication. Our aim was to describe the process, facilitators, and barriers to completing the first 2-week full SR. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We systematically reviewed evidence of the impact of increased fluid intake, on urinary tract infection (UTI) recurrence, in individuals at risk for UTIs. The review was conducted by experienced systematic reviewers with complementary skills (two researcher clinicians, an information specialist, and an epidemiologist), using Systematic Review Automation tools, and blocked off time for the duration of the project. The outcomes were time to complete the SR, time to complete individual SR tasks, facilitators and barriers to progress, and peer reviewer feedback on the SR manuscript. Times to completion were analyzed quantitatively (minutes and calendar days); facilitators and barriers were mapped onto the Theoretical Domains Framework; and peer reviewer feedback was analyzed quantitatively and narratively. RESULTS: The SR was completed in 61 person-hours (9 workdays; 12 calendar days); accepted version of the manuscript required 71 person-hours. Individual SR tasks ranged from 16 person-minutes (deduplication of search results) to 461 person-minutes (data extraction). The least time-consuming SR tasks were obtaining full-texts, searches, citation analysis, data synthesis, and deduplication. The most time-consuming tasks were data extraction, write-up, abstract screening, full-text screening, and risk of bias. Facilitators and barriers mapped onto the following domains: knowledge; skills; memory, attention, and decision process; environmental context and resources; and technology and infrastructure. Two sets of peer reviewer feedback were received on the manuscript: the first included 34 comments requesting changes, 17 changes were made, requiring 173 person-minutes; the second requested 13 changes, and eight were made, requiring 121 person-minutes. CONCLUSION: A small and experienced systematic reviewer team using Systematic Review Automation tools who have protected time to focus solely on the SR can complete a moderately sized SR in 2 weeks.
引用
- Clark J, Glasziou P, Del Mar C, et al. A full systematic review was completed in 2 weeks using automation tools: a case study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 32004673. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.01.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。