贝叶斯分层荟萃分析方法:利用聚合数据建模跨治疗类别的替代关系
针对替代终点在不同治疗类别间替代关系存在差异时验证困难的问题,本文提出两种贝叶斯荟萃分析方法,允许在探索特定治疗类别的替代关系时从其他类别借用信息。第一种方法假设所有治疗类别的替代关系完全可交换,第二种方法允许部分可交换以避免过度借用。模拟研究在九种数据场景下评估了方法,并应用于结直肠癌实例,获得了更高精度的替代关系参数。
要点
- 当替代关系跨治疗类别变化时,分层贝叶斯模型可借用其他类别信息提高估计精度。
- 完全可交换假设可能过度借用信息,部分可交换方法可缓解该问题。
- 结直肠癌实例中,所提方法获得了更高精度的替代关系参数。
核心结论
- 两种贝叶斯分层荟萃分析方法可在替代关系跨治疗类别变化时借用其他类别信息,提高参数估计精度。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,提出两种贝叶斯荟萃分析模型,并进行模拟研究(九种数据场景)和结直肠癌实例应用。
主要发现
- 模拟研究在九种数据场景下评估了所提方法,并与每个治疗类别内使用标准模型的亚组分析进行比较。
- 结直肠癌实例应用所提方法获得了更高精度的替代关系参数。
临床怎么用
- 在替代终点验证中,当治疗类别间替代关系可能不同时,可考虑使用分层贝叶斯模型借用信息。
- 需根据治疗类别间替代关系的可交换性假设选择完全或部分交换模型,以避免过度借用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Surrogate endpoints play an important role in drug development when they can be used to measure treatment effect early compared to the final clinical outcome and to predict clinical benefit or harm. Such endpoints are assessed for their predictive value of clinical benefit by investigating the surrogate relationship between treatment effects on the surrogate and final outcomes using meta-analytic methods. When surrogate relationships vary across treatment classes, such validation may fail due to limited data within each treatment class. In this paper, two alternative Bayesian meta-analytic methods are introduced which allow for borrowing of information from other treatment classes when exploring the surrogacy in a particular class. The first approach extends a standard model for the evaluation of surrogate endpoints to a hierarchical meta-analysis model assuming full exchangeability of surrogate relationships across all the treatment classes, thus facilitating borrowing of information across the classes. The second method is able to relax this assumption by allowing for partial exchangeability of surrogate relationships across treatment classes to avoid excessive borrowing of information from distinctly different classes. We carried out a simulation study to assess the proposed methods in nine data scenarios and compared them with subgroup analysis using the standard model within each treatment class. We also applied the methods to an illustrative example in colorectal cancer which led to obtaining the parameters describing the surrogate relationships with higher precision.
引用
- Papanikos T, Thompson JR, Abrams KR, et al. Bayesian hierarchical meta-analytic methods for modeling surrogate relationships that vary across treatment classes using aggregate data. Stat Med. 2020. PMID: 31990083. doi:10.1002/sim.8465
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。