仅用标题、摘要和关键词检索在流行病学实践系统综述中文献回收率低
该研究基于文本挖掘方法,比较了2000至2017年5种顶级流行病学期刊中所有文章的检索策略。研究分析了9个方法学主题在标题、摘要、关键词和正文中的提及情况,共下载31,641个HTML文件。结果显示,对于所有主题和期刊,正文提及某主题的文章中最多50%也在标题、摘要或关键词中提及该主题;部分主题在标题、摘要或关键词中的报告随时间逐渐减少。结论提示仅基于标题、摘要和关键词的文献检索对流行病学研究实践研究可能不够敏感。
要点
- 正文提及方法学主题的文章中,最多50%也在标题、摘要或关键词中提及该主题。
- 部分方法学主题在标题、摘要或关键词中的报告随时间逐渐减少。
- 仅用标题、摘要和关键词检索可能漏检流行病学研究实践相关文献。
核心结论
- 仅基于标题、摘要和关键词的文献检索对流行病学研究实践研究可能不够敏感。
- 全文检索具有潜在价值,前提是全文正文可检索。
研究设计与样本
- 基于文本挖掘方法,系统综述2000至2017年5种顶级流行病学期刊的所有文章。
- 共下载31,641个HTML文件,分析9个方法学主题在标题、摘要、关键词和正文中的提及情况。
主要发现
- 对于所有方法学主题和期刊,正文提及某主题的文章中最多50%也在标题、摘要或关键词中提及该主题。
- 部分主题在标题、摘要或关键词中的报告随时间逐渐减少。
临床怎么用
- 在流行病学研究实践的系统综述中,应考虑全文检索以提高敏感性。
- 仅依赖标题、摘要和关键词检索可能遗漏相关文献。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Article full texts are often inaccessible via the standard search engines of biomedical literature, such as PubMed and Embase, which are commonly used for systematic reviews. Excluding the full-text bodies from a literature search may result in a small or selective subset of articles being included in the review because of the limited information that is available in only title, abstract, and keywords. This article describes a comparison of search strategies based on a systematic literature review of all articles published in 5 top-ranked epidemiology journals between 2000 and 2017. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Based on a text-mining approach, we studied how nine different methodological topics were mentioned across text fields (title, abstract, keywords, and text body). The following methodological topics were studied: propensity score methods, inverse probability weighting, marginal structural modeling, multiple imputation, Kaplan-Meier estimation, number needed to treat, measurement error, randomized controlled trial, and latent class analysis. RESULTS: In total, 31,641 Hypertext Markup Language (HTML) files were downloaded from the journals' websites. For all methodological topics and journals, at most 50% of articles with a mention of a topic in the text body also mentioned the topic in the title, abstract, or keywords. For several topics, a gradual decrease over calendar time was observed of reporting in the title, abstract, or keywords. CONCLUSION: Literature searches based on title, abstract, and keywords alone may not be sufficiently sensitive for studies of epidemiological research practice. This study also illustrates the potential value of full-text literature searches, provided there is accessibility of full-text bodies for literature searches.
引用
- Penning de Vries BBL, van Smeden M, Rosendaal FR, et al. Title, abstract, and keyword searching resulted in poor recovery of articles in systematic reviews of epidemiologic practice. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020. PMID: 31982541. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.01.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。