文献速递流行病学与生物统计真实世界研究与卫生经济

医疗事故责任与医疗质量:一项综述

Malpractice Liability and Health Care Quality: A Review.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA · 2020-01-01

该综述系统检索1990年至2019年间发表的文献,评估医疗事故责任风险与医疗质量及安全的关系。现有证据提示,更严格的侵权责任(至少在当前形式下)与医疗质量的改善无关。

要点

  • 多数研究未发现医疗事故责任风险与医疗质量指标存在显著关联
  • 在产科研究中,9项未发现显著关联,7项证据有限
  • 在非产科患者死亡率研究中,15项未发现关联,5项证据有限

核心结论

  • 多数研究未发现医疗事故责任风险与医疗质量及结局存在关联
  • 现有证据提示更严格的侵权责任(至少在当前形式下)与医疗质量改善无关

主要发现

  • 产科研究中,9项未发现责任风险与结局(如Apgar评分和产伤)显著关联,7项证据有限
  • 非产科患者死亡率研究中,15项未发现关联,5项证据有限
  • 再入院和可避免住院研究中,均未发现关联
  • 其他指标(如患者安全指标、过程质量、满意度)研究中,7项未发现关联,5项在某些分析中发现显著关联

临床怎么用

  • 临床实践中应关注医疗质量改进的其他驱动因素,而非仅依赖侵权责任压力

局限性

  • 由于研究设计差异,无法进行荟萃分析,仅作描述性总结和定性评估
  • 证据仍存在 gaps

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

IMPORTANCE: The tort liability system is intended to serve 3 functions: compensate patients who sustain injury from negligence, provide corrective justice, and deter negligence. Deterrence, in theory, occurs because clinicians know that they may experience adverse consequences if they negligently injure patients. OBJECTIVE: To review empirical findings regarding the association between malpractice liability risk (ie, the extent to which clinicians face the threat of being sued and having to pay damages) and health care quality and safety. DATA SOURCES AND STUDY SELECTION: Systematic search of multiple databases for studies published between January 1, 1990, and November 25, 2019, examining the relationship between malpractice liability risk measures and health outcomes or structural and process indicators of health care quality. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Information on the exposure and outcome measures, results, and acknowledged limitations was extracted by 2 reviewers. Meta-analytic pooling was not possible due to variations in study designs; therefore, studies were summarized descriptively and assessed qualitatively. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Associations between malpractice risk measures and health care quality and safety outcomes. Exposure measures included physicians' malpractice insurance premiums, state tort reforms, frequency of paid claims, average claim payment, physicians' claims history, total malpractice payments, jury awards, the presence of an immunity from malpractice liability, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' Medicare malpractice geographic practice cost index, and composite measures combining these measures. Outcome measures included patient mortality; hospital readmissions, avoidable admissions, and prolonged length of stay; receipt of cancer screening; Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality patient safety indicators and other measures of adverse events; measures of hospital and nursing home quality; and patient satisfaction. RESULTS: Thirty-seven studies were included; 28 examined hospital care only and 16 focused on obstetrical care. Among obstetrical care studies, 9 found no significant association between liability risk and outcomes (such as Apgar score and birth injuries) and 7 found limited evidence for an association. Among 20 studies of patient mortality in nonobstetrical care settings, 15 found no evidence of an association with liability risk and 5 found limited evidence. Among 7 studies that examined hospital readmissions and avoidable initial hospitalizations, none found evidence of an association between liability risk and outcomes. Among 12 studies of other measures (eg, patient safety indicators, process-of-care quality measures, patient satisfaction), 7 found no association between liability risk and these outcomes and 5 identified significant associations in some analyses. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this systematic review, most studies found no association between measures of malpractice liability risk and health care quality and outcomes. Although gaps in the evidence remain, the available findings suggested that greater tort liability, at least in its current form, was not associated with improved quality of care.

来源:JAMA,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mello MM, Frakes MD, Blumenkranz E, et al. Malpractice Liability and Health Care Quality: A Review. JAMA. 2020. PMID: 31990319. doi:10.1001/jama.2019.21411

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。