卒中康复随机对照试验招募效率的系统综述
该系统综述旨在探讨卒中康复随机对照试验(RCT)的招募效率及相关试验特征。研究检索了35个电子数据库等来源,纳入2005至2015年间发表的512项RCT(共28804名卒中幸存者参与者)。结果显示,筛查的卒中幸存者中约三分之一同意参与(中位数34%),平均每中心每月招募1.5人,6%的参与者脱落;社区招募比例(48%)高于医院(27%),卒中后至少6个月筛查的参与率(47%)高于卒中后1个月内(23%)。
要点
- 卒中康复RCT筛查者中约三分之一被随机入组,每中心每月平均招募1.5人。
- 社区招募和卒中后较晚筛查的参与率更高,专职招募人员可提高招募速度。
- 亚洲试验招募更快且脱落更少,但招募细节报告有限限制亚组分析。
核心结论
- 卒中康复RCT筛查的卒中幸存者约三分之一被随机入组,每中心每月招募1至2人,二十分之一未完成试验。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索Cochrane卒中组试验注册库等35个电子数据库、临床试验注册库及手工检索,纳入2005至2015年发表的512项卒中康复RCT(n=28804)。
主要发现
- 筛查者中同意参与的中位数为34%(IQR 14-61),平均每中心每月招募1.5人(IQR 0.71-3.22),6%(IQR 0-13)的参与者脱落。
- 社区筛查者中48%被招募,医院环境下为27%;卒中后至少6个月筛查者中47%参与,卒中后1个月内筛查者为23%。
- 一名招募人员负责多个中心时中位每2个月招募1人,每中心有专职招募人员时每月超过2人。
- 亚洲试验每中心每月招募近3人、脱落2%,欧洲试验每月约1人、脱落7%,亚洲试验招募显著更快且脱落更少。
临床怎么用
- 未来卒中康复RCT制定招募计划时可参考社区招募、延迟筛查窗口及专职招募人员以提高效率。
局限性
- 招募细节报告有限,限制了所进行的亚组分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) that fail to meet their recruitment target risk increasing research waste. Acute stroke RCTs experience notable recruitment issues. The efficiency of recruitment to stroke rehabilitation RCTs has not been explored. AIMS AND OBJECTIVES: To explore recruitment efficiency and the trial features associated with efficient recruitment to stroke rehabilitation RCTs. METHODS: A systematic review of stroke rehabilitation RCTs published between 2005 and 2015 identified in a search of the Cochrane Stroke Group (CSG) Trials Register from 35 electronic databases (e.g. Medline, CINAHL; EMBASE), clinical trial registers, and hand-searching. Inclusion criteria are stroke rehabilitation intervention, delivered by a member of the rehabilitation team, and clinically relevant environment. We extracted data on recruitment efficiency and trial features. RESULTS: We screened 12,939 titles, 1270 abstracts and 788 full texts, before extracting data from 512 included RCTs (n = 28,804 stroke survivor participants). This is the largest systematic review of recruitment to date. A third of stroke survivors screened consented to participate (median 34% (IQR 14-61), on average sites recruited 1.5 participants per site per month (IQR 0.71-3.22), and one in twenty (6% (IQR 0-13) dropped out during the RCT. Almost half (48%) of those screened in the community were recruited compared to hospital settings (27%). Similarly, almost half (47%) those screened at least 6 months after stroke participated, compared to 23% of stroke survivors screened within a month of stroke. When one recruiter screened multiple sites, a median of one stroke survivor was recruited every 2 months compared to more than two per month when there was a dedicated recruiter per site. RCT recruitment was significantly faster per site, with fewer dropouts, for trials conducted in Asia (almost three stroke survivors monthly; 2% dropout) compared to European trials (approximately one stroke survivor monthly; 7% dropout). CONCLUSIONS: One third of stroke survivors screened were randomised to rehabilitation RCTs at a rate of between one and two per month, per site. One in twenty did not complete the trial. Our findings will inform recruitment plans of future stroke rehabilitation RCTs. Limited reporting of recruitment details restricted the subgroup analysis performed. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews, registration number CRD42016033067.
引用
- McGill K, Sackley CM, Godwin J, et al. A systematic review of the efficiency of recruitment to stroke rehabilitation randomised controlled trials. Trials. 2020. PMID: 31924252. doi:10.1186/s13063-019-3991-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。