比较准确性系统评价的方法与报告存在缺陷:一项方法学调查与报告指南建议
该研究对127篇发表于74种期刊的比较多种诊断试验准确性的系统评价进行方法学调查,发现仅13%限制纳入比较准确性研究,42%进行统计比较但仅34%使用推荐方法,多个报告条目存在缺陷,并据此提出报告指南。
要点
- 比较多种诊断试验准确性的系统评价在方法学和报告质量上普遍不足。
- 仅13%的评价限制纳入比较准确性研究,87%纳入任意研究类型。
- 42%的评价进行了统计比较,其中仅34%使用推荐方法。
核心结论
- 评估和比较多种诊断试验的系统评价报告质量较差,所开发的指南可帮助作者提高比较性系统评价的质量。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学调查纳入127篇比较或多种诊断试验的系统评价,发表于74种综合医学和专科期刊。
- 总结单试验评价与比较性评价可能不同的方法和报告特征,并开发改进报告指南。
主要发现
- 127篇评价中16篇(13%)将研究选择和试验比较限制于比较准确性研究,其余111篇(87%)纳入任意研究类型。
- 多个报告条目存在缺陷,尤其是索引试验的作用、试验比较策略和间接比较的局限性。
- 识别出5篇方法和报告 exemplary 的评价。
临床怎么用
- 系统评价作者在比较多种诊断试验准确性时应参考所开发的指南和范例,改进报告质量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to examine methodological and reporting characteristics of systematic reviews and meta-analyses which compare diagnostic test accuracy (DTA) of multiple index tests, identify good practice, and develop guidance for better reporting. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Methodological survey of 127 comparative or multiple tests reviews published in 74 different general medical and specialist journals. We summarized methods and reporting characteristics that are likely to differ between reviews of a single test and comparative reviews. We then developed guidance to enhance reporting of test comparisons in DTA reviews. RESULTS: Of 127 reviews, 16 (13%) reviews restricted study selection and test comparisons to comparative accuracy studies while the remaining 111 (87%) reviews included any study type. Fifty-three reviews (42%) statistically compared test accuracy with only 18 (34%) of these using recommended methods. Reporting of several items-in particular the role of the index tests, test comparison strategy, and limitations of indirect comparisons (i.e., comparisons involving any study type)-was deficient in many reviews. Five reviews with exemplary methods and reporting were identified. CONCLUSION: Reporting quality of reviews which evaluate and compare multiple tests is poor. The guidance developed, complemented with the exemplars, can assist review authors in producing better quality comparative reviews.
引用
- Takwoingi Y, Partlett C, Riley RD, et al. Methods and reporting of systematic reviews of comparative accuracy were deficient: a methodological survey and proposed guidance. J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 31843693. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.12.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。