提升随机试验对初级保健的相关性:关于实用型试验与PRECIS-2工具观点的定性研究
本研究通过对英国17名影响初级保健实践的人士进行半结构化访谈,探讨其对随机试验设计、实用型方法及PRECIS-2各领域的看法。结果显示,完全采用实用型方法未必总能提高试验结果对初级保健的适用性,在干预实施灵活性、资源水平和依从性改进强度方面需权衡,而在人群和试验环境方面实用型方法更合适。
要点
- 试验应尽量采用与初级保健一致的人群和环境以提高相关性。
- 干预实施灵活性、资源投入和依从性改进强度需在试验中适当权衡。
- 并非所有PRECIS-2领域都越实用越好,需结合具体领域判断。
核心结论
- 为最大化以初级保健为导向的研究相关性,试验应采用与初级保健相同的人群和环境;但在其他方面不一定需要完全匹配实践条件。
研究设计与样本
- 对英国初级保健实践有影响力的人士进行半结构化访谈,采用框架法进行主题分析,精英样本共17人(个体或小组访谈)。
主要发现
- 完全实用型方法未必总能使试验结果更适用于初级保健。
- 在干预实施方式上,试验中减少灵活性可能优于实践中的做法。
- 在资源水平和改进依从性的步骤强度上需取得适当平衡。
- 在人群和试验环境等其他方面,实用型方法被视为更合适。
临床怎么用
- 设计面向初级保健的试验时,应优先匹配初级保健的人群和环境。
- 在干预实施灵活性、资源投入和依从性改进强度上,不应盲目追求完全实用化,需权衡试验需求与实践适用性。
局限性
- 样本为17名精英人士的定性访谈,结果可能不具广泛代表性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Pragmatic trials have been suggested as a way to improve the relevance of clinical trial results to practice. PRECIS-2 (Pragmatic Explanatory Continuum Indicator Summary-2) is a trial design tool which considers how pragmatic a trial is across a number of domains. It is not known whether a pragmatic approach to all PRECIS-2 domains leads to results being more relevant to primary care. The aim of this study was to investigate the views of people with influence on primary care practice towards the design of randomised trials, pragmatic approaches to trial design, and the PRECIS-2 domains. METHODS: We carried out semi-structured interviews with people who influence practice in primary care in the UK. A thematic analysis was undertaken using the framework approach. RESULTS: We conducted individual or small group interviews involving an elite sample of 17 individuals. We found that an exclusively pragmatic approach to randomised trials may not always make the results of trials more applicable to primary care. For example, it may be better to have less flexibility in the way interventions are delivered in randomised trials than in practice. In addition, an appropriate balance needs to be struck when thinking about levels of resourcing and the intensity of steps needed to improve adherence in a trial. Across other aspects of a trial's design, for example the population and trial setting, a pragmatic approach was viewed as more appropriate. CONCLUSIONS: To maximize the relevance of research directed at primary care, trials should be conducted with the same populations and settings that are found in primary care. Across other aspects of trials it is not always necessary to match the conditions found in practice.
引用
- Forbes G, Loudon K, Clinch M, et al. Improving the relevance of randomised trials to primary care: a qualitative study investigating views towards pragmatic trials and the PRECIS-2 tool. Trials. 2019. PMID: 31829266. doi:10.1186/s13063-019-3812-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。