文献速递临床试验与 GCP流行病学与生物统计

利用早期终点进行决策的自适应双臂临床试验:肩峰下间隔物修复肩袖撕裂研究设计

An adaptive two-arm clinical trial using early endpoints to inform decision making: design for a study of sub-acromial spacers for repair of rotator cuff tendon tears.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2019-12-09

针对新外科手术的 RCT 常昂贵耗时,尤其在干预不优于标准时效率低。本文提出一种自适应 group sequential 设计,允许早期终点参与决策,并通过模拟和实例展示其可行性和优于传统设计的潜力。方法基于正在进行的肩峰下球囊间隔物治疗肩袖撕裂的试验,模拟显示一次、两次和三次早期查看的设计可行,合理选择无效停止边界后具有良好把握度和高概率提前停止。

要点

  • 自适应 group sequential 设计可利用早期终点做决策,减少无效试验的资源消耗。
  • 模拟显示 1–3 次早期查看的设计可行,合理无效边界下把握度和提前停止概率良好。
  • 为 START:REACTS 研究提供停止边界取值指南和 R 代码实例。

核心结论

  • 自适应设计可行,并可在实际研究中应用;本文描述了设计操作特征并为 START:REACTS 研究提供停止边界取值指南。

研究设计与样本

  • 方法学文章,基于两个早期结局设定检验统计量,描述序贯停止边界估计方法和模拟评估设计特征的框架。
  • 以正在进行的肩峰下盐水填充球囊(关节镜清创后植入肩关节上方)治疗肩袖撕裂的临床试验为动机和实例。

主要发现

  • 模拟显示一次、两次和三次早期查看的设计可行,合理选择无效停止边界后具有良好设计特征。
  • 多种设计选项在早期查看无疗效证据时具有良好把握度和高概率因无效而停止。
  • 提供含 R 代码的实例演示设计在实际研究中的运行方式。

临床怎么用

  • 在外科手术 RCT 中可考虑采用自适应 group sequential 设计,利用早期终点提前停止无效试验以节省资源。
  • 实施时需通过模拟评估设计特征,并合理选择无效停止边界。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: There is widespread concern across the clinical and research communities that clinical trials, powered for patient-reported outcomes, testing new surgical procedures are often expensive and time-consuming, particularly when the new intervention is shown to be no better than the standard. Conventional (non-adaptive) randomised controlled trials (RCTs) are perceived as being particularly inefficient in this setting. Therefore, we have developed an adaptive group sequential design that allows early endpoints to inform decision making and show, through simulations and a worked example, that these designs are feasible and often preferable to conventional non-adaptive designs. The methodology is motivated by an ongoing clinical trial investigating a saline-filled balloon, inserted above the main joint of the shoulder at the end of arthroscopic debridement, for treatment of tears of rotor cuff tendons. This research question and setting is typical of many studies undertaken to assess new surgical procedures. METHODS: Test statistics are presented based on the setting of two early outcomes, and methods for estimation of sequential stopping boundaries are described. A framework for the implementation of simulations to evaluate design characteristics is also described. RESULTS: Simulations show that designs with one, two and three early looks are feasible and, with appropriately chosen futility stopping boundaries, have appealing design characteristics. A number of possible design options are described that have good power and a high probability of stopping for futility if there is no evidence of a treatment effect at early looks. A worked example, with code in R, provides a practical demonstration of how the design might work in a real study. CONCLUSIONS: In summary, we show that adaptive designs are feasible and could work in practice. We describe the operating characteristics of the designs and provide guidelines for appropriate values for the stopping boundaries for the START:REACTS (Sub-acromial spacer for Tears Affecting Rotator cuff Tendons: a Randomised, Efficient, Adaptive Clinical Trial in Surgery) study. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN Registry, ISRCTN17825590. Registered on 5 March 2018.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Parsons N, Stallard N, Parsons H, et al. An adaptive two-arm clinical trial using early endpoints to inform decision making: design for a study of sub-acromial spacers for repair of rotator cuff tendon tears. Trials. 2019. PMID: 31815651. doi:10.1186/s13063-019-3708-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。