CHIRPY DRAGON干预预防中国小学学龄儿童肥胖:整群随机对照试验
在中国广州40所公立小学开展整群随机对照试验,共1641名一年级儿童参与,干预组832名、对照组809名,干预为期12个月。主要结局BMI z评分组间平均差为-0.13(95%CI -0.26至0.00,p=0.048),女生和基线超重或肥胖儿童中效果更大。成本效果估计为每获得一个QALY花费1760英镑,未发现不良效应。
要点
- 12个月学校与家庭联合干预使BMI z评分组间平均差为-0.13(95%CI -0.26至0.00,p=0.048)。
- 女生中平均差为-0.18(95%CI -0.32至-0.05,p=0.007),基线超重或肥胖儿童中为-0.49(95%CI -0.73至-0.25,p<0.001)。
- 成本效果估计为每QALY 1760英镑,在每QALY支付意愿阈值20000至30000英镑下成本有效的概率至少95%。
核心结论
- 该学校与家庭为基础的肥胖预防方案在降低中国小学学龄儿童BMI z评分方面有效且成本效果高。
- 未来研究应识别增强男生中有益效果的策略,并研究该干预向中国其他省份及共享相同语言和文化的国家推广的可能性。
研究设计与样本
- 整群随机对照试验,从中国广州城区招募40所公立小学。
- 共1641名一年级儿童在基线评估前经家长或监护人同意参与,学校分层随机化后干预组20所学校832名儿童(平均年龄6.15岁,55.6%为男孩),对照组809名儿童(平均年龄6.14岁,53.3%为男孩)。
- 12个月干预方案包括4个学校与家庭为基础的组成部分,由5名专职项目人员实施。
- 主要结局为干预完成时BMI z评分的组间差异,评估对分组设盲。
- 采用意向性治疗分析,失访55名儿童(3.4%),无学校退出。
主要发现
- BMI z评分平均差(干预组减对照组)为-0.13(95%CI -0.26至0.00,p=0.048)。
- 女生中平均差为-0.18(95%CI -0.32至-0.05,p=0.007,交互作用p=0.015),基线超重或肥胖儿童中平均差为-0.49(95%CI -0.73至-0.25,p<0.001,交互作用p<0.001)。
- 干预组在水果蔬菜、含糖饮料和不健康零食消费、屏幕久坐行为及身体活动方面也观察到显著有益干预效果。
- 成本效果估计为每QALY 1760英镑,在每QALY支付意愿阈值20000至30000英镑下,与常规照护相比成本有效的概率至少95%。
- 未发现不良效应或危害的证据。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 使用尚未在中国儿童中验证的膳食评估工具。
- 使用英国价值集估算QALY。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In countries undergoing rapid economic transition such as China, rates of increase in childhood obesity exceed that in the West. However, prevention trials in these countries are inadequate in both quantity and methodological quality. In high-income countries, recent reviews have demonstrated that school-based prevention interventions are moderately effective but have some methodological limitations. To address these issues, this study evaluated clinical- and cost- effectiveness of the Chinese Primary School Children Physical Activity and Dietary Behaviour Changes Intervention (CHIRPY DRAGON) developed using the United Kingdom Medical Research Council complex intervention framework to prevent obesity in Chinese primary-school-aged children. METHODS AND FINDINGS: In this cluster-randomised controlled trial, we recruited 40 state-funded primary schools from urban districts of Guangzhou, China. A total of 1,641 year-one children with parent/guardian consent took part in baseline assessments prior to stratified randomisation of schools (intervention arm, 20 schools, n = 832, mean age = 6.15 years, 55.6% boys; control arm n = 809, mean age = 6.14 years, 53.3% boys). The 12-month intervention programme included 4 school- and family-based components delivered by 5 dedicated project staff. We promoted physical activity and healthy eating behaviours through educational and practical workshops, family activities, and supporting the school to improve physical activity and food provision. The primary outcome, assessed blind to allocation, was between-arm difference in body mass index (BMI) z score at completion of the intervention. A range of prespecified, secondary anthropometric, behavioural, and psychosocial outcomes were also measured. We estimated cost effectiveness based on quality-adjusted life years (QALYs), taking a public sector perspective. Attrition was low with 55 children lost to follow up (3.4%) and no school dropout. Implementation adherence was high. Using intention to treat analysis, the mean difference (MD) in BMI z scores (intervention - control) was -0.13 (-0.26 to 0.00, p = 0.048), with the effect being greater in girls (MD = -0.18, -0.32 to -0.05, p = 0.007, p for interaction = 0.015) and in children with overweight or obesity at baseline (MD = -0.49, -0.73 to -0.25, p < 0.001, p for interaction < 0.001). Significant beneficial intervention effects were also observed on consumption of fruit and vegetables, sugar-sweetened beverages and unhealthy snacks, screen-based sedentary behaviour, and physical activity in the intervention group. Cost effectiveness was estimated at £1,760 per QALY, with the probability of the intervention being cost effective compared with usual care being at least 95% at a willingness to pay threshold of £20,000 to 30,000 per QALY. There was no evidence of adverse effects or harms. The main limitations of this study were the use of dietary assessment tools not yet validated for Chinese children and the use of the UK value set to estimate QALYS. CONCLUSIONS: This school- and family-based obesity prevention programme was effective and highly cost effective in reducing BMI z scores in primary-school-aged children in China. Future research should identify strategies to enhance beneficial effects among boys and investigate the transferability of the intervention to other provinces in China and countries that share the same language and cultures. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN Identifier ISRCTN11867516.
引用
- Li B, Pallan M, Liu WJ, et al. The CHIRPY DRAGON intervention in preventing obesity in Chinese primary-school--aged children: A cluster-randomised controlled trial. PLoS Med. 2019. PMID: 31770371. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002971
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。