回答同一临床问题的荟萃分析间差异难以解释:一项荟萃流行病学研究
该研究系统比较了Cochrane综述与非Cochrane综述中回答同一临床问题的荟萃分析合并效应估计的差异,匹配了24对荟萃分析(含545项随机对照试验)。非Cochrane综述的合并效应平均高0.12个对数单位(13%),仅1对结果相同;方法学差异和作者判断是导致纳入研究重叠差和效应估计不一致的关键因素。
要点
- 非Cochrane综述合并效应平均比Cochrane综述高0.12个对数单位(13%),仅1对结果相同。
- 24对中仅2对就同一研究的数据达成一致,纳入研究重叠差与作者判断相关。
- Cochrane综述70.8%(15/24)获中高置信度评分,非Cochrane综述为0/20(0%)。
核心结论
- 非Cochrane综述的荟萃分析合并效应估计平均高于回答同一临床问题的Cochrane综述荟萃分析。
- 方法学、作者判断和实施是导致纳入研究重叠差和报告效应估计不一致的关键方面。
- 对卫生保健政策和临床实践的潜在影响深远但仍未知。
- 需要加强对报告指南应用的认识和审查,并改进方案注册。
研究设计与样本
- 对Cochrane综述与非Cochrane综述中按人群、干预、疾病和结局匹配的荟萃分析效应估计一致性进行定量和定性分析。
- 共识别24对匹配荟萃分析,来自24篇Cochrane综述与20篇非Cochrane综述,涉及545项随机对照试验。
主要发现
- 与匹配的Cochrane综述相比,非Cochrane综述的合并效应仅1对相同,平均高0.12个对数单位(13%)(P=0.012)。
- 4对匹配分析中非Cochrane综述的效应量大于两倍。
- Cochrane综述中70.8%(15/24)被评为中至高置信度,非Cochrane综述为0/20(0%)(AMSTAR 2)。
- 搜索策略、纳入标准、双人筛选等预设方法差异可解释纳入研究的不匹配。
- 14对分析中,对纳入标准解释的分歧被确定为结果差异的原因。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To systematically explore the methodological factors underpinning discrepancies in the pooled effect estimates from Cochrane reviews (CRs) and non-Cochrane reviews (NCRs) systematic reviews, answering the same clinical question. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Quantitative and qualitative analysis of concordance in effect estimates between meta-analyses from CR and NCR matched on population, intervention, condition, and outcome. RESULTS: We identified 24 matched meta-analyses from 24 CR to 20 NCR reviews (545 randomized controlled trials [RCTs]). Compared to their CR matched-pair, pooled effects from NCR were the same in only one pair, were on average 0.12 log units (13%) higher (P = 0.012), and had a greater than twofold larger effect size in four matched-pairs. Two-thirds of CR (15/24, 70.8%) and 0/20 (0%) NCR were rated to have moderate to high confidence in their results (AMSTAR 2). Differences in pre-defined methods, including search strategy, eligibility criteria, and performance of dual screening, could explain mismatches in included studies. Disagreements in the interpretation of eligibility criteria were identified as reasons underpinning discrepant findings in 14 pairs. 23/24 meta-analyses included at least one study of its match. Only two pairs agreed on the numerical data presented for the same studies. An assessment of 50% of discrepant studies (n = 45) showed that reasons for differences in extracted data could be identified in 15 studies. CONCLUSION: On average, meta-analyses from NCR reported higher effect estimates compared with meta-analyses from CR answering the same clinical question. Methodological and author judgments and performance are key aspects underpinning poor overlap of included studies and discrepancies in reported effect estimates. The potential impacts on health care policy and clinical practice are far-reaching but still remain unknown. Reinforcing awareness and scrutiny of application of reporting guidelines and improvements in protocol registration are needed.
引用
- Hacke C, Nunan D. Discrepancies in meta-analyses answering the same clinical question were hard to explain: a meta-epidemiological study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 31783099. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.11.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。