存在定性协变量-治疗交互作用时治疗分层变点的置信区间估计
针对 stratified medicine 中连续协变量与治疗存在定性交互作用的情形,研究比较了 Fieller 定理、delta 法及多种 bootstrap 方法对治疗推荐改变变点的置信区间估计,并通过模拟研究和一项比较症状性重度颈动脉狭窄两种治疗的随机临床试验数据进行了评估。
要点
- Fieller 定理在各样本量下覆盖率合适,但置信区间很宽甚至无限。
- delta 法和 wild bootstrap 区间最短,但小到中等事件数下覆盖率不足。
- 百分位 bootstrap 区间较宽且覆盖率略保守,正态 bootstrap 多数场景不可接受。
核心结论
- Fieller 定理在各样本量下覆盖率合适,但代价是置信区间非常宽甚至无限。
- delta 法和 wild bootstrap 提供最小置信区间,但在小到中等事件数下覆盖率不足,且取决于真实变点的位置。
研究设计与样本
- 模拟研究比较 Fieller 定理、delta 法和不同 bootstrap 方法(正态、百分位、wild bootstrap)对变点置信区间的估计。
- 方法应用于一项比较两种治疗的症状性重度颈动脉狭窄随机临床试验数据,以患者年龄作为预测标志物。
主要发现
- Fieller 定理在各样本量下覆盖率合适,但置信区间非常宽甚至无限。
- delta 法和 wild bootstrap 提供最小置信区间,但在小到中等事件数下覆盖率不足,且取决于真实变点位置。
- 百分位 bootstrap 区间较宽且覆盖率略保守,正态 bootstrap 在许多场景下未提供可接受结果。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The goal in stratified medicine is to administer the "best" treatment to a patient. Not all patients might benefit from the same treatment; the choice of best treatment can depend on certain patient characteristics. In this article, it is assumed that a time-to-event outcome is considered as a patient-relevant outcome and a qualitative interaction between a continuous covariate and treatment exists, ie, that patients with different values of one specific covariate should be treated differently. We suggest and investigate different methods for confidence interval estimation for the covariate value, where the treatment recommendation should be changed based on data collected in a randomized clinical trial. An adaptation of Fieller's theorem, the delta method, and different bootstrap approaches (normal, percentile-based, wild bootstrap) are investigated and compared in a simulation study. Extensions to multivariable problems are presented and evaluated. We observed appropriate confidence interval coverage following Fieller's theorem irrespective of sample size but at the cost of very wide or even infinite confidence intervals. The delta method and the wild bootstrap approach provided the smallest intervals but inadequate coverage for small to moderate event numbers, also depending on the location of the true changepoint. For the percentile-based bootstrap, wide intervals were observed, and it was slightly conservative regarding coverage, whereas the normal bootstrap did not provide acceptable results for many scenarios. The described methods were also applied to data from a randomized clinical trial comparing two treatments for patients with symptomatic, severe carotid artery stenosis, considering patient's age as predictive marker.
引用
- Haller B, Mansmann U, Dobler D, et al. Confidence interval estimation for the changepoint of treatment stratification in the presence of a qualitative covariate-treatment interaction. Stat Med. 2019. PMID: 31701549. doi:10.1002/sim.8404
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。