文献速递流行病学与生物统计

识别网络Meta分析中的不一致性:网状热图是否可靠?

Identifying inconsistency in network meta-analysis: Is the net heat plot a reliable method?
PubMed 文献 · Stat Med · 2019-10-24

网状热图是识别随机对照试验网络不一致性的图形工具,但在7531例肺癌患者个体参与者数据网络中未发现重要不一致性,与Bucher法、Cochran Q统计量、节点拆分和不一致参数法在5%水平提示不一致性的结果矛盾;理论工作表明其计算构成直接与间接证据的任意加权,模拟研究和10种糖尿病治疗网络Meta分析进一步表明网状热图不能可靠提示不一致性或识别导致不一致的设计。

要点

  • 在7531例肺癌患者网络中网状热图未发现重要不一致性,而Bucher法、Cochran Q、节点拆分和不一致参数法均在5%水平提示不一致性。
  • 理论分析显示网状热图的计算构成直接与间接证据的任意加权,可能产生误导。
  • 模拟研究和10种糖尿病治疗网络Meta分析进一步表明网状热图不能可靠提示不一致性或识别导致不一致的设计。

核心结论

  • 网状热图不能可靠提示不一致性或识别导致不一致的设计。

研究设计与样本

  • 方法学研究,包括理论分析、模拟研究以及应用于7531例肺癌患者个体参与者数据的网络Meta分析和10种糖尿病治疗的网络Meta分析。

主要发现

  • 在7531例肺癌患者个体参与者数据网络中,网状热图未发现重要不一致性证据,而Bucher法、Cochran Q统计量、节点拆分和不一致参数法均在5%水平提示网络内存在不一致性证据。
  • 理论工作表明网状热图的计算构成直接与间接证据的任意加权,可能产生误导。
  • 模拟研究和10种糖尿病治疗网络Meta分析进一步说明了上述问题。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

One of the biggest challenges for network meta-analysis is inconsistency, which occurs when the direct and indirect evidence conflict. Inconsistency causes problems for the estimation and interpretation of treatment effects and treatment contrasts. Krahn and colleagues proposed the net heat approach as a graphical tool for identifying and locating inconsistency within a network of randomized controlled trials. For networks with a treatment loop, the net heat plot displays statistics calculated by temporarily removing each design one at a time, in turn, and assessing the contribution of each remaining design to the inconsistency. The net heat plot takes the form of a matrix which is displayed graphically with coloring indicating the degree of inconsistency in the network. Applied to a network of individual participant data assessing overall survival in 7531 patients with lung cancer, we were surprised to find no evidence of important inconsistency from the net heat approach; this contradicted other approaches for assessing inconsistency such as the Bucher approach, Cochran's Q statistic, node-splitting, and the inconsistency parameter approach, which all suggested evidence of inconsistency within the network at the 5% level. Further theoretical work shows that the calculations underlying the net heat plot constitute an arbitrary weighting of the direct and indirect evidence which may be misleading. We illustrate this further using a simulation study and a network meta-analysis of 10 treatments for diabetes. We conclude that the net heat plot does not reliably signal inconsistency or identify designs that cause inconsistency.

来源:Stat Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Freeman SC, Fisher D, White IR, et al. Identifying inconsistency in network meta-analysis: Is the net heat plot a reliable method? Stat Med. 2019. PMID: 31647136. doi:10.1002/sim.8383

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。