网络Meta分析中基于臂模型与基于对比模型的比较
本文比较了Lu-Ades的基于对比(CB)模型、Hong等的基于臂(AB)模型及两个中间模型,使用假设数据和一组选定真实数据。差异主要源于研究截距在Lu-Ades模型中为固定效应而在Hong模型中为随机效应,并识别出四个关键差异。结论认为AB和CB模型均适用于网络Meta分析,但使用随机研究截距需要强有力的理由。
要点
- 研究截距为固定效应时仅利用研究内信息,为随机效应时还利用研究间信息并可能引起重要偏倚。
- 随机研究截距模型适合推导更广泛的估计量(如边际风险差),但基线风险通常最好来自外部数据。
- Hong模型允许治疗效应与研究截距相关,Lu-Ades模型不允许;Hong模型在臂缺失随机假设下有效但未减少偏倚。
核心结论
- AB和CB模型均适用于网络Meta分析数据分析,但使用随机研究截距需要强有力的理由,例如将治疗效应与研究截距关联。
研究设计与样本
- 比较Lu-Ades(2006)的CB模型、Hong等(2016)的AB模型及两个中间模型,使用假设数据和一组选定真实数据。
主要发现
- 差异主要源于研究截距在Lu-Ades模型中为固定效应而在Hong模型中为随机效应,并识别出四个关键差异。
- 研究截距为固定效应时仅利用研究内信息,为随机效应时还利用研究间信息并可能引起重要偏倚。
- 随机研究截距模型适合推导更广泛的估计量(如边际风险差),但基线风险通常最好来自外部数据,此时固定截距模型同样好。
- Hong模型允许治疗效应与研究截距相关,Lu-Ades模型不允许。
- Hong模型在臂(而非对比)缺失随机的更宽松缺失数据假设下有效,但这似乎并未减少偏倚。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Differences between arm-based (AB) and contrast-based (CB) models for network meta-analysis (NMA) are controversial. We compare the CB model of Lu and Ades (2006), the AB model of Hong et al(2016), and two intermediate models, using hypothetical data and a selected real data set. Differences between models arise primarily from study intercepts being fixed effects in the Lu-Ades model but random effects in the Hong model, and we identify four key difference. (1) If study intercepts are fixed effects then only within-study information is used, but if they are random effects then between-study information is also used and can cause important bias. (2) Models with random study intercepts are suitable for deriving a wider range of estimands, eg, the marginal risk difference, when underlying risk is derived from the NMA data; but underlying risk is usually best derived from external data, and then models with fixed intercepts are equally good. (3) The Hong model allows treatment effects to be related to study intercepts, but the Lu-Ades model does not. (4) The Hong model is valid under a more relaxed missing data assumption, that arms (rather than contrasts) are missing at random, but this does not appear to reduce bias. We also describe an AB model with fixed study intercepts and a CB model with random study intercepts. We conclude that both AB and CB models are suitable for the analysis of NMA data, but using random study intercepts requires a strong rationale such as relating treatment effects to study intercepts.
引用
- White IR, Turner RM, Karahalios A, et al. A comparison of arm-based and contrast-based models for network meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2019. PMID: 31583750. doi:10.1002/sim.8360
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。