分析(非)优先复合终点的广义成对比较方法
在临床试验复合终点分析中,logrank检验和Cox比例风险检验未考虑事件的多样性、重要性和严重程度。本文总结了四种广义成对比较方法(Finkelstein-Schoenfeld、Buyse、非匹配Pocock和改良O'Brien检验),通过模拟比较它们与logrank检验,并评估复合终点各组分间相关性对检验效能的影响。模拟显示,优先化广义成对比较方法表现相似,对组分优先等级敏感,且从第二优先等级组分起不能测量真实治疗效应;非优先化成对比较检验不受这些限制,相关性仅影响其方差。
要点
- 优先化广义成对比较方法对复合终点组分优先等级敏感,从第二优先等级起不能测量真实治疗效应。
- 非优先化成对比较检验不受优先等级限制,相关性仅影响其方差。
- 四种广义成对比较方法可纳入纵向定量结局等所有类型结局以评估全面治疗效应。
核心结论
- 优先化广义成对比较方法表现相似,对复合终点组分优先等级敏感,且从第二优先等级组分起不能测量真实治疗效应。
- 非优先化成对比较检验不受这些限制,相关性仅影响其方差。
研究设计与样本
- 模拟研究,比较四种广义成对比较方法(Finkelstein-Schoenfeld、Buyse、非匹配Pocock和改良O'Brien检验)与logrank检验,评估复合终点组分间相关性对检验效能的影响。
主要发现
- 优先化广义成对比较方法表现非常相似。
- 优先化方法对复合终点组分的优先等级敏感。
- 优先化方法从第二优先等级组分起不能测量真实治疗效应。
- 非优先化成对比较检验不受这些限制,相关性仅影响其方差。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In the analysis of composite endpoints in a clinical trial, time to first event analysis techniques such as the logrank test and Cox proportional hazard test do not take into account the multiplicity, importance, and the severity of events in the composite endpoint. Several generalized pairwise comparison analysis methods have been described recently that do allow to take these aspects into account. These methods have the additional benefit that all types of outcomes can be included, such as longitudinal quantitative outcomes, to evaluate the full treatment effect. Four of the generalized pairwise comparison methods, ie, the Finkelstein-Schoenfeld, the Buyse, unmatched Pocock, and adapted O'Brien test, are summarized. They are compared to each other and to the logrank test by means of simulations while specifically evaluating the effect of correlation between components of the composite endpoint on the power to detect a treatment difference. These simulations show that prioritized generalized pairwise comparison methods perform very similarly, are sensitive to the priority rank of the components in the composite endpoint, and do not measure the true treatment effect from the second priority-ranked component onward. The nonprioritized pairwise comparison test does not suffer from these limitations and correlation affects only its variance.
引用
- Verbeeck J, Spitzer E, de Vries T, et al. Generalized pairwise comparison methods to analyze (non)prioritized composite endpoints. Stat Med. 2019. PMID: 31659790. doi:10.1002/sim.8388
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。