全科实践中 Fear Reduction Exercised Early(FREE)方法管理腰背痛:一项实用性整群随机对照试验
在新西兰8家全科诊所开展实用性整群随机对照试验,比较FREE方法与常规全科诊疗对腰背痛的效果。6个月时两组Roland Morris功能障碍问卷评分差异无统计学意义(校正均值差0.57,95%CI -0.64至1.78;p=0.354),FREE组全科医生态度、知识和信心改善且管理行为更符合指南,干预在成本效果上占优。
要点
- 6个月时FREE组与常规组RMDQ评分差异无统计学意义(校正均值差0.57,95%CI -0.64至1.78;p=0.354)。
- FREE组全科医生的态度、知识和信心较对照组改善,腰背痛管理行为更符合指南。
- 成本效果分析中FREE方法优于常规诊疗,成本更低且QALY增益更高。
核心结论
- FREE方法提高全科医生对腰背痛指南推荐的依从性,但与常规诊疗相比未改善患者康复结局。
- FREE方法可能减少不必要的医疗使用并产生经济效益。
- 未来针对未分化腰背痛的试验应考虑将工作参与或卫生资源使用作为主要结局评估。
研究设计与样本
- 实用性整群随机对照试验,含过程评估和平行经济学评价,在新西兰Hutt Valley开展。
- 8家全科诊所按诊所规模分层以1:1随机分配至干预组(4家诊所;34名全科医生)或对照组(4家诊所;29名全科医生)。
- 2016年9月23日至2017年7月31日,干预组140例合格患者就诊(126例入组),对照组110例合格患者就诊(100例入组)。
- 患者平均年龄46.1岁(SD 14.4),46%为女性,88%患者腰背痛病程少于6周。
- 主要结局为6个月时患者Roland Morris功能障碍问卷(RMDQ)评分较基线的变化,分析遵循意向性治疗原则。
主要发现
- 6个月时两组主要结局无显著差异(校正均值RMDQ评分差0.57,95%CI -0.64至1.78;p=0.354),次要患者结局亦无显著差异。
- RMDQ差异达到预设的非劣效性标准。
- 干预组122例(97%)患者来自32名全科医生、对照组99例(99%)患者来自25名全科医生纳入主要结局分析。
- 干预组全科医生的态度、知识和信心较对照组改善,其腰背痛管理行为较对照组更符合指南。
- 成本效果方面,干预优于对照,成本更低且质量调整生命年(QALY)增益更高。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 研究对主要结局评估有足够把握度,但对某些就业、医疗使用和经济结局的评估把握度不足。
- 负责患者招募的研究护士无法对诊所分组设盲。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Effective and cost-effective primary care treatments for low back pain (LBP) are required to reduce the burden of the world's most disabling condition. This study aimed to compare the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of the Fear Reduction Exercised Early (FREE) approach to LBP (intervention) with usual general practitioner (GP) care (control). METHODS AND FINDINGS: This pragmatic, cluster-randomised controlled trial with process evaluation and parallel economic evaluation was conducted in the Hutt Valley, New Zealand. Eight general practices were randomly assigned (stratified by practice size) with a 1:1 ratio to intervention (4 practices; 34 GPs) or control group (4 practices; 29 GPs). Adults presenting to these GPs with LBP as their primary complaint were recruited. GPs in the intervention practices were trained in the FREE approach, and patients presenting to these practices received care based on the FREE approach. The FREE approach restructures LBP consultations to prioritise early identification and management of barriers to recovery. GPs in control practices did not receive specific training for this study, and patients presenting to these practices received usual care. Between 23 September 2016 and 31 July 2017, 140 eligible patients presented to intervention practices (126 enrolled) and 110 eligible patients presented to control practices (100 enrolled). Patient mean age was 46.1 years (SD 14.4), and 46% were female. The duration of LBP was less than 6 weeks in 88% of patients. Primary outcome was change from baseline in patient participant Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire (RMDQ) score at 6 months. Secondary patient outcomes included pain, satisfaction, and psychosocial indices. GP outcomes included attitudes, knowledge, confidence, and GP LBP management behaviour. There was active and passive surveillance of potential harms. Patients and outcome assessors were blind to group assignment. Analysis followed intention-to-treat principles. A total of 122 (97%) patients from 32 GPs in the intervention group and 99 (99%) patients from 25 GPs in the control group were included in the primary outcome analysis. At 6 months, the groups did not significantly differ on the primary outcome (adjusted mean RMDQ score difference 0.57, 95% CI -0.64 to 1.78; p = 0.354) or secondary patient outcomes. The RMDQ difference met the predefined criterion to indicate noninferiority. One control group participant experienced an activity-related gluteal tear, with no other adverse events recorded. Intervention group GPs had improvements in attitudes, knowledge, and confidence compared with control group GPs. Intervention group GP LBP management behaviour became more guideline concordant than the control group. In cost-effectiveness, the intervention dominated control with lower costs and higher Quality-Adjusted Life Year (QALY) gains. Limitations of this study were that although adequately powered for primary outcome assessment, the study was not powered for evaluating some employment, healthcare use, and economic outcomes. It was also not possible for research nurses (responsible for patient recruitment) to be masked on group allocation for practices. CONCLUSIONS: Findings from this study suggest that the FREE approach improves GP concordance with LBP guideline recommendations but does not improve patient recovery outcomes compared with usual care. The FREE approach may reduce unnecessary healthcare use and produce economic benefits. Work participation or health resource use should be considered for primary outcome assessment in future trials of undifferentiated LBP. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ACTRN12616000888460.
引用
- Darlow B, Stanley J, Dean S, et al. The Fear Reduction Exercised Early (FREE) approach to management of low back pain in general practice: A pragmatic cluster-randomised controlled trial. PLoS Med. 2019. PMID: 31498799. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002897
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。