酷刑幸存者的心理、社会与福利干预:随机对照试验的系统综述与Meta分析
该研究更新2014年系统综述,纳入15项随机对照试验、来自10个国家的1373名成年酷刑幸存者,评估心理、社会或福利干预对比常规治疗或主动对照的效果。心理干预在治疗结束时降低创伤后应激障碍症状(SMD -0.31,95%CI -0.52至-0.09,p=0.005)并改善功能(SMD -0.38,95%CI -0.58至-0.18,p=0.0002),但随访时创伤后应激障碍症状未显著降低(SMD -0.34,95%CI -0.74至0.06,p=0.09),抑郁症状及生活质量未见显著改善,未发现社会或福利干预的试验。
要点
- 心理干预在治疗结束时降低创伤后应激障碍症状(SMD -0.31,95%CI -0.52至-0.09,p=0.005),但随访时未显著降低(SMD -0.34,95%CI -0.74至0.06,p=0.09)。
- 心理干预在治疗结束时改善功能(SMD -0.38,95%CI -0.58至-0.18,p=0.0002),随访时仅一项研究未显示改善。
- 抑郁症状在治疗结束(SMD -0.23,95%CI -0.50至0.03,p=0.09)和随访(SMD -0.23,95%CI -0.70至0.24,p=0.34)均未见显著改善;生活质量在治疗结束未见显著改善(SMD 0.38,95%CI -0.28至1.05,p=0.26)。
核心结论
- 心理干预改善治疗结束时的创伤后应激障碍症状和功能,但随访时是否维持未知,一项研究显示随访时创伤后应激障碍可能加重(n=28)。
- 该人群的进一步干预应关注创伤后应激障碍之外的更广泛心理需求,并考虑日常多重应激源的影响。
- 需开展包括社会与福利干预在内的更多研究以提高效应估计的精确性,尤其是长期效果。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,更新2014年综述,检索2014年1月1日至2019年6月22日发表的随机对照试验。
- 纳入标准为成年酷刑幸存者,比较任何心理、社会或福利干预与常规治疗或主动对照。
- 共纳入15项随机对照试验,来自10个国家(欧洲7项、亚洲5项、非洲3项),1373名参与者(女性589名,男性784名)。
- 未发现社会或福利干预的试验。
- 主要结局为创伤后应激障碍症状或病例状态,次要结局为抑郁症状、功能、生活质量及不良反应,评估时间点为治疗结束时及至少3个月随访。
主要发现
- 与多为非活跃(等待名单)对照相比,心理干预在治疗结束时降低创伤后应激障碍症状(SMD -0.31,95%CI -0.52至-0.09,p=0.005),但随访时未显著降低(SMD -0.34,95%CI -0.74至0.06,p=0.09)。
- 治疗结束时创伤后应激障碍病例状态未见显著改善,一项研究(n=28)显示随访时可能加重。
- 治疗结束时抑郁症状未见显著改善(SMD -0.23,95%CI -0.50至0.03,p=0.09),随访时亦未见显著改善(SMD -0.23,95%CI -0.70至0.24,p=0.34)。
- 与对照相比,心理干预在治疗结束时显著改善功能(SMD -0.38,95%CI -0.58至-0.18,p=0.0002),但随访时仅一项研究未显示改善。
- 治疗结束时生活质量未见显著改善(SMD 0.38,95%CI -0.28至1.05,p=0.26),随访时无可用数据。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 该领域难以确定是否捕获所有合格研究。
- 缺乏对治疗效果维持情况的建模。
- 多数SMD精确度低,随着新研究发表,结果可能发生变化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Torture and other forms of ill treatment have been reported in at least 141 countries, exposing a global crisis. Survivors face multiple physical, psychological, and social difficulties. Psychological consequences for survivors are varied, and evidence on treatment is mixed. We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to estimate the benefits and harms of psychological, social, and welfare interventions for torture survivors. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We updated a 2014 review with published randomised controlled trials (RCTs) for adult survivors of torture comparing any psychological, social, or welfare intervention against treatment as usual or active control from 1 January 2014 through 22 June 2019. Primary outcome was post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms or caseness, and secondary outcomes were depression symptoms, functioning, quality of life, and adverse effects, after treatment and at follow-up of at least 3 months. Standardised mean differences (SMDs) and odds ratios were estimated using meta-analysis with random effects. The Cochrane tool was used to derive risk of bias. Fifteen RCTs were included, with data from 1,373 participants (589 females and 784 males) in 10 countries (7 trials in Europe, 5 in Asia, and 3 in Africa). No trials of social or welfare interventions were found. Compared to mostly inactive (waiting list) controls, psychological interventions reduced PTSD symptoms by the end of treatment (SMD -0.31, 95% confidence interval [CI] -0.52 to -0.09, p = 0.005), but PTSD symptoms at follow-up were not significantly reduced (SMD -0.34, 95% CI -0.74 to 0.06, p = 0.09). No significant improvement was found for PTSD caseness at the end of treatment, and there was possible worsening at follow-up from one study (n = 28). Interventions showed no benefits for depression symptoms at end of treatment (SMD -0.23, 95% CI -0.50 to 0.03, p = 0.09) or follow-up (SMD -0.23, 95% CI -0.70 to 0.24, p = 0.34). A significant improvement in functioning for psychological interventions compared to control was found at end of treatment (SMD -0.38, 95% CI -0.58 to -0.18, p = 0.0002) but not at follow-up from only one study. No significant improvement emerged for quality of life at end of treatment (SMD 0.38, 95% CI -0.28 to 1.05, p = 0.26) with no data available at follow-up. The main study limitations were the difficulty in this field of being certain of capturing all eligible studies, the lack of modelling of maintenance of treatment gains, and the low precision of most SMDs making findings liable to change with the addition of further studies as they are published. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings show evidence that psychological interventions improve PTSD symptoms and functioning at the end of treatment, but it is unknown whether this is maintained at follow-up, with a possible worsening of PTSD caseness at follow-up from one study. Further interventions in this population should address broader psychological needs beyond PTSD while taking into account the effect of multiple daily stressors. Additional studies, including social and welfare interventions, will improve precision of estimates of effect, particularly over the longer term.
引用
- Hamid A, Patel N, Williams ACC, et al. Psychological, social, and welfare interventions for torture survivors: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. PLoS Med. 2019. PMID: 31550249. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002919
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。