存在暴露诱导的中介-结局混杂时通过多个因果非有序中介的效应分解
Avin等(2005)表明,在存在暴露诱导的中介-结局混杂时,即使在全混杂因素均可观测的非参数结构方程模型下,使用标准条件可交换性假设也无法分解总因果效应(TCE)。本文扩展VanderWeele等(2014)的方法,处理多个互不直接影响但均受暴露诱导的中介-结局混杂因素影响的中介,并提供来自巴西1982年Pelotas出生队列牙科流行病学工作的动机示例和模拟研究结果。
要点
- 在暴露诱导的中介-结局混杂下,标准条件可交换性假设无法分解总因果效应。
- VanderWeele等(2014)提出三种场景下分解TCE的方法。
- 本文将其扩展至多个因果非有序但均受同一暴露诱导混杂影响的中介。
核心结论
- 本文扩展了VanderWeele等(2014)的效应分解方法,适用于多个互不直接影响但均受暴露诱导的中介-结局混杂因素影响的中介。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学论文,基于非参数结构方程模型框架进行理论扩展,并包含基于巴西1982年Pelotas出生队列牙科流行病学工作的模拟研究。
主要发现
- Avin等(2005)表明在暴露诱导的中介-结局混杂下,使用标准条件可交换性假设无法分解总因果效应(TCE),即使在全混杂因素可观测的非参数结构方程模型下亦然。
- VanderWeele等(2014)在三种场景下分解TCE:(1)将中介和暴露诱导的混杂因素视为联合中介;(2)生成路径特异性效应但不区分通过暴露诱导混杂因素的多条不同路径;(3)使用随机干预类似物,从暴露水平内中介分布中采样以边际化暴露诱导混杂因素。
- 本文将该方法扩展至多个不直接相互影响但均受暴露诱导的中介-结局混杂因素影响的中介。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Avin et al (2005) showed that, in the presence of exposure-induced mediator-outcome confounding, decomposing the total causal effect (TCE) using standard conditional exchangeability assumptions is not possible even under a nonparametric structural equation model with all confounders observed. Subsequent research has investigated the assumptions required for such a decomposition to be identifiable and estimable from observed data. One approach was proposed by VanderWeele et al (2014). They decomposed the TCE under three different scenarios: (1) treating the mediator and the exposure-induced confounder as joint mediators; (2) generating path-specific effects albeit without distinguishing between multiple distinct paths through the exposure-induced confounder; and (3) using so-called randomised interventional analogues where sampling values from the distribution of the mediator within the levels of the exposure effectively marginalises over the exposure-induced confounder. In this paper, we extend their approach to the case where there are multiple mediators that do not influence each other directly but which are all influenced by an exposure-induced mediator-outcome confounder. We provide a motivating example and results from a simulation study based on from our work in dental epidemiology featuring the 1982 Pelotas Birth Cohort in Brazil.
引用
- Mittinty MN, Lynch JW, Forbes AB, et al. Effect decomposition through multiple causally nonordered mediators in the presence of exposure-induced mediator-outcome confounding. Stat Med. 2019. PMID: 31475385. doi:10.1002/sim.8352
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。