多组分家庭物理治疗干预对老年髋部骨折后步行能力的影响:CAP随机临床试验
这项在美国3个临床中心开展的平行两组随机临床试验纳入210例60岁及以上非病理性轻微创伤髋部骨折后居住于社区且日常活动不能行走的老年患者,比较多组分家庭物理治疗训练与主动对照(经皮电神经刺激和主动关节活动度训练)对16周时社区步行能力(6分钟步行≥300米)的影响。结果显示训练组96例中22例(22.9%)、对照组101例中18例(17.8%)达到社区步行,差异5.1%(单侧97.5%CI,-∞至16.3%;单侧P=0.19),未达统计学显著。
要点
- 训练组22.9%与对照组17.8%达到6分钟步行≥300米,差异未达统计学显著(单侧P=0.19)。
- 两组各105例,均接受每周2至3次家庭访视共16周、营养咨询及每日维生素D 2000 IU、钙600 mg和多种维生素。
- 训练组17例(16.2%)、对照组15例(14.3%)发生1次及以上可报告不良事件,最常见为跌倒。
核心结论
- 在老年髋部骨折患者中,与包含经皮电神经刺激和主动关节活动度训练的主动对照相比,多组分家庭物理治疗干预未使16周后6分钟步行300米及以上的能力获得统计学显著改善。
研究设计与样本
- 平行两组随机临床试验,在美国3个临床中心(Arcadia University、University of Connecticut Health Center和University of Maryland,Baltimore)开展。
- 随机化自2013年9月16日开始至2017年6月20日结束,随访于2017年10月17日结束。
- 纳入60岁及以上、非病理性轻微创伤髋部骨折后居住于社区且骨折前无需他人帮助即可行走、住院后26周内评估、入组时日常活动不能行走的患者,共210例随机分组并在16周和40周后重新评估。
主要发现
- 210例随机参与者平均年龄80.8岁,女性161例(76.7%);197例(93.8%)完成试验(187例[89.0%]通过完成16周6分钟步行测试,10例[4.8%]通过主要结局裁定)。
- 训练组96例中22例(22.9%)与主动对照组101例中18例(17.8%)成为社区步行者,差异5.1%(单侧97.5%CI,-∞至16.3%;单侧P=0.19)。
- 训练组17例(16.2%)与对照组15例(14.3%)在干预期间发生1次及以上可报告不良事件。
- 最常见可报告不良事件为跌倒(训练组6例[5.7%],对照组4例[3.8%])、股骨/髋部骨折(每组各2例)、肺炎(训练组2例,对照组0例)、尿路感染(训练组2例,对照组0例)、脱水(训练组0例,对照组2例)和呼吸困难(训练组0例,对照组2例)。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局社区步行定义为随机化后16周时6分钟步行300米及以上。
- 研究设计为检验训练优于主动对照的单侧假设。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Disability persists after hip fracture in older persons. Current rehabilitation may not be sufficient to restore ability to walk in the community. OBJECTIVE: To compare a multicomponent home-based physical therapy intervention (training) with an active control on ability to walk in the community. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Parallel, 2-group randomized clinical trial conducted at 3 US clinical centers (Arcadia University, University of Connecticut Health Center, and University of Maryland, Baltimore). Randomization began on September 16, 2013, and ended on June 20, 2017; follow-up ended on October 17, 2017. Patients aged 60 years and older were enrolled after nonpathologic, minimal trauma hip fracture, if they were living in the community and walking without human assistance before the fracture, were assessed within 26 weeks of hospitalization, and were not able to walk during daily activities at the time of enrollment. A total of 210 participants were randomized and reassessed 16 and 40 weeks later. INTERVENTIONS: The training intervention (active treatment) (n = 105) included aerobic, strength, balance, and functional training. The active control group (n = 105) received transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation and active range-of-motion exercises. Both groups received 2 to 3 home visits from a physical therapist weekly for 16 weeks; nutritional counseling; and daily vitamin D (2000 IU), calcium (600 mg), and multivitamins. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome (community ambulation) was defined as walking 300 m or more in 6 minutes at 16 weeks after randomization. The study was designed to test a 1-sided hypothesis of superiority of training compared with active control. RESULTS: Among 210 randomized participants (mean age, 80.8 years; 161 women [76.7%]), 197 (93.8%) completed the trial (187 [89.0%] by completing the 6-minute walk test at 16 weeks and 10 [4.8%] by adjudication of the primary outcome). Among these, 22 of 96 training participants (22.9%) and 18 of 101 active control participants (17.8%) (difference, 5.1% [1-sided 97.5% CI, -∞ to 16.3%]; 1-sided P = .19) became community ambulators. Seventeen training participants (16.2%) and 15 control participants (14.3%) had 1 or more reportable adverse events during the intervention period. The most common reportable adverse events reported were falls (training: 6 [5.7%], control: 4 [3.8%]), femur/hip fracture (2 in each group), pneumonia (training: 2, control: 0), urinary tract infection (training: 2, control: 0), dehydration (training: 0, control: 2), and dyspnea (training: 0, control: 2). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Among older adults with a hip fracture, a multicomponent home-based physical therapy intervention compared with an active control that included transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation and active range-of-motion exercises did not result in a statistically significant improvement in the ability to walk 300 m or more in 6 minutes after 16 weeks. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01783704.
引用
- Magaziner J, Mangione KK, Orwig D, et al. Effect of a Multicomponent Home-Based Physical Therapy Intervention on Ambulation After Hip Fracture in Older Adults: The CAP Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA. 2019. PMID: 31503309. doi:10.1001/jama.2019.12964
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。