在动态干预的复杂场景中使用纵向靶向最大似然估计
纵向靶向最大似然估计(LTMLE)很少用于存在受既往治疗影响的时依混杂、长随访、多时变混杂及复杂关联的场合。本文以HIV治疗研究为例,展示LTMLE在复杂现实场景中可成功应用并与竞争估计量比较,模拟揭示其在样本量小、建模选项受限时的表现,并提供实践指导。
要点
- LTMLE具有双重稳健性,可与机器学习结合,标准误易解析计算,无需自助法。
- 示例展示长随访(30个月)、样本量渐减、部分干预规则支持有限、高维调整变量及碰撞偏倚等挑战。
- 模拟显示LTMLE在样本量小、建模选项受限时可获稳定良好估计,简单学习器组合可优于单一复杂模型。
核心结论
- LTMLE在复杂现实场景中可成功应用,即使样本量小、建模选项受限也能获得稳定且良好的估计。
- 机器学习的表现可因干预措施及其数据支持程度不同而差异很大,每个LTMLE分析应伴随关键质量检查。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学论文,以HIV治疗研究的实际数据为例,并将结果与竞争估计量比较,同时进行模拟研究。
主要发现
- 示例具有长随访时间(30个月)、样本量逐渐下降、部分干预规则支持有限、高维潜在调整变量集及需考虑碰撞偏倚等挑战。
- 使用一小组简单学习器的机器学习(若无法拟合更复杂模型)可优于针对先验临床知识定制的单一复杂模型。
- LTMLE的性能可因干预措施及其数据支持程度不同而差异很大。
临床怎么用
- 每个LTMLE分析应伴随关键质量检查。
- 在无法拟合复杂模型时,可考虑使用一小组简单学习器的机器学习。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Longitudinal targeted maximum likelihood estimation (LTMLE) has very rarely been used to estimate dynamic treatment effects in the context of time-dependent confounding affected by prior treatment when faced with long follow-up times, multiple time-varying confounders, and complex associational relationships simultaneously. Reasons for this include the potential computational burden, technical challenges, restricted modeling options for long follow-up times, and limited practical guidance in the literature. However, LTMLE has desirable asymptotic properties, ie, it is doubly robust, and can yield valid inference when used in conjunction with machine learning. It also has the advantage of easy-to-calculate analytic standard errors in contrast to the g-formula, which requires bootstrapping. We use a topical and sophisticated question from HIV treatment research to show that LTMLE can be used successfully in complex realistic settings, and we compare results to competing estimators. Our example illustrates the following practical challenges common to many epidemiological studies: (1) long follow-up time (30 months); (2) gradually declining sample size; (3) limited support for some intervention rules of interest; (4) a high-dimensional set of potential adjustment variables, increasing both the need and the challenge of integrating appropriate machine learning methods; and (5) consideration of collider bias. Our analyses, as well as simulations, shed new light on the application of LTMLE in complex and realistic settings: We show that (1) LTMLE can yield stable and good estimates, even when confronted with small samples and limited modeling options; (2) machine learning utilized with a small set of simple learners (if more complex ones cannot be fitted) can outperform a single, complex model, which is tailored to incorporate prior clinical knowledge; and (3) performance can vary considerably depending on interventions and their support in the data, and therefore critical quality checks should accompany every LTMLE analysis. We provide guidance for the practical application of LTMLE.
引用
- Schomaker M, Luque-Fernandez MA, Leroy V, et al. Using longitudinal targeted maximum likelihood estimation in complex settings with dynamic interventions. Stat Med. 2019. PMID: 31436859. doi:10.1002/sim.8340
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。