两部分肱骨近端骨折的手术治疗与非手术治疗:一项多中心随机对照试验
该多中心随机对照试验在芬兰、爱沙尼亚、瑞典和丹麦的6家医院纳入88例60岁及以上、移位超过1厘米或45度的两部分肱骨近端骨折患者,1:1随机分入锁定钢板手术组或非手术组。2年时DASH评分手术组18.5分与非手术组17.4分,平均差异1.1(95%CI -7.8至9.4,p=0.81),所有结局指标均无统计学或临床显著差异。作者认为对多数老年移位两部分肱骨近端骨折患者行手术可能并无获益。
要点
- 2年时DASH评分手术组18.5分与非手术组17.4分,平均差异1.1(95%CI -7.8至9.4,p=0.81)。
- 2年时所有结局指标均无统计学或临床显著组间差异。
- 导致二次手术的3例并发症均发生于手术组。
核心结论
- 该试验发现60岁及以上移位两部分肱骨近端骨折患者手术与非手术治疗2年临床结局无显著差异。
- 作者认为当前对多数老年移位肱骨近端两部分骨折行手术的实践可能并无获益。
研究设计与样本
- NITEP组在芬兰、爱沙尼亚、瑞典和丹麦的6家医院开展优越性、评估者盲法、多中心随机对照试验。
- 88例60岁及以上、移位超过1厘米或45度的两部分外科颈或解剖颈肱骨近端骨折患者按1:1随机分入锁定钢板手术组或非手术组。
- 非手术组平均年龄72岁、手术组73岁,女性比例分别为95%和87%。
- 患者于2011年2月至2016年4月招募,主要结局为2年随访时上肢、肩和手功能障碍(DASH)评分。
主要发现
- 2年时DASH评分(0分最好、100分最差)手术组18.5分 vs 非手术组17.4分,平均差异1.1(95%CI -7.8至9.4,p=0.81)。
- 2年时所有结局指标均无统计学或临床显著组间差异。
- 导致二次手术的3例并发症均发生于手术组。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局为2年随访时DASH评分。
- 次要结局包括Constant-Murley评分、疼痛视觉模拟量表、15D生活质量问卷、EQ-5D、Oxford肩关节评分和并发症。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为当前对多数老年移位肱骨近端两部分骨折行手术的实践可能并无获益。
局限性
- 患者报告结局评估缺乏盲法为研究局限,但评估物理治疗师设盲。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Although increasingly used, the benefit of surgical treatment of displaced 2-part proximal humerus fractures has not been proven. This trial evaluates the clinical effectiveness of surgery with locking plate compared with non-operative treatment for these fractures. METHODS AND FINDINGS: The NITEP group conducted a superiority, assessor-blinded, multicenter randomized trial in 6 hospitals in Finland, Estonia, Sweden, and Denmark. Eighty-eight patients aged 60 years or older with displaced (more than 1 cm or 45 degrees) 2-part surgical or anatomical neck proximal humerus fracture were randomly assigned in a 1:1 ratio to undergo either operative treatment with a locking plate or non-operative treatment. The mean age of patients was 72 years in the non-operative group and 73 years in the operative group, with a female sex distribution of 95% and 87%, respectively. Patients were recruited between February 2011 and April 2016. The primary outcome measure was Disabilities of Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score at 2-year follow-up. Secondary outcomes included Constant-Murley score, the visual analogue scale for pain, the quality of life questionnaire 15D, EuroQol Group's 5-dimension self-reported questionnaire EQ-5D, the Oxford Shoulder Score, and complications. The mean DASH score (0 best, 100 worst) at 2 years was 18.5 points for the operative treatment group and 17.4 points for the non-operative group (mean difference 1.1 [95% CI -7.8 to 9.4], p = 0.81). At 2 years, there were no statistically or clinically significant between-group differences in any of the outcome measures. All 3 complications resulting in secondary surgery occurred in the operative group. The lack of blinding in patient-reported outcome assessment is a limitation of the study. Our assessor physiotherapists were, however, blinded. CONCLUSIONS: This trial found no significant difference in clinical outcomes at 2 years between surgery and non-operative treatment in patients 60 years of age or older with displaced 2-part fractures of the proximal humerus. These results suggest that the current practice of performing surgery on the majority of displaced proximal 2-part fractures of the humerus in older adults may not be beneficial. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01246167.
引用
- Launonen AP, Sumrein BO, Reito A, et al. Operative versus non-operative treatment for 2-part proximal humerus fracture: A multicenter randomized controlled trial. PLoS Med. 2019. PMID: 31318863. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002855
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。