二项比例的贝叶斯共识样本量准则
针对二项比例样本量计算中先验意见分歧问题,提出考虑先验密度社区变异性的贝叶斯样本量方法,通过诱导后验一致性达到预设程度来确定所需样本量,并给出单样本与两样本二项结局的原型示例,与既往基于区间的贝叶斯准则样本量进行比较。
要点
- 提出考虑先验意见变异性的贝叶斯样本量方法,以诱导后验一致性至预设程度。
- 给出单样本与两样本二项结局的原型示例。
- 将考虑先验族的准则样本量与既往基于区间的贝叶斯准则所得样本量进行比较。
核心结论
- 提出方法通过提供诱导后验一致性至预设程度所需的样本量,来考虑先验意见的变异性。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,针对二项比例样本量准则,纳入单样本与两样本二项结局的原型示例。
主要发现
- 既往无相应样本量方法专门考虑先验密度社区以确保样本量足够大、使数据充分压倒先验从而在广泛分歧的先验观点间达成共识。
- 本文方法考虑先验意见变异性,提供诱导后验一致性至预设程度所需的样本量。
- 比较了考虑先验族的准则样本量与既往基于区间的贝叶斯准则所得样本量。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Many sample size criteria exist. These include power calculations and methods based on confidence interval widths from a frequentist viewpoint, and Bayesian methods based on credible interval widths or decision theory. Bayesian methods account for the inherent uncertainty of inputs to sample size calculations through the use of prior information rather than the point estimates typically used by frequentist methods. However, the choice of prior density can be problematic because there will almost always be different appreciations of the past evidence. Such differences can be accommodated a priori by robust methods for Bayesian design, for example, using mixtures or ϵ-contaminated priors. This would then ensure that the prior class includes divergent opinions. However, one may prefer to report several posterior densities arising from a "community of priors," which cover the range of plausible prior densities, rather than forming a single class of priors. To date, however, there are no corresponding sample size methods that specifically account for a community of prior densities in the sense of ensuring a large-enough sample size for the data to sufficiently overwhelm the priors to ensure consensus across widely divergent prior views. In this paper, we develop methods that account for the variability in prior opinions by providing the sample size required to induce posterior agreement to a prespecified degree. Prototypic examples to one- and two-sample binomial outcomes are included. We compare sample sizes from criteria that consider a family of priors to those that would result from previous interval-based Bayesian criteria.
引用
- Joseph L, Bélisle P. Bayesian consensus-based sample size criteria for binomial proportions. Stat Med. 2019. PMID: 31297825. doi:10.1002/sim.8316
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。