在健康关系早期干预试验(THRIVE)中,对增强型婴儿三重P与Mellow Bumps进行现实主义过程评估:一项随机对照试验的研究方案
THRIVE是一项三臂随机对照试验,旨在评估产前和产后早期干预(增强型婴儿三重P(ETPB)加常规照护或Mellow Bumps(MB)加常规照护,对比单独常规照护)能否改善有复杂健康和社会照护需求的孕妇的心理健康与福祉、改善母婴依恋与互动、减少儿童虐待并改善儿童语言习得。本文聚焦THRIVE的现实主义过程评估,采用混合方法设计,包括培训前后问卷、会后评估表、参与观察、半结构化访谈和电话访谈,以考察干预的实施忠实度、作用机制及情境因素。
要点
- THRIVE试验评估ETPB加常规照护或MB加常规照护对比单独常规照护对孕妇心理健康、母婴依恋、儿童虐待和语言习得的效果。
- 过程评估采用现实主义评估理论,混合定量问卷与定性访谈及观察方法。
- 定性数据收集包括对培训者和干预组(ETPB组n=3,MB组n=3)产前课程系列的参与观察,以及对培训者、孕妇、伴侣和转介培训者的半结构化访谈。
核心结论
- 过程评估结果将帮助研究者和决策者解释THRIVE的结果,并增进对干预如何起作用(如果确实起作用)、实施的程度和质量、促进和限制干预运作的情境因素、脆弱父母亚组内部和之间的反应差异以及两种干预的益处或意外后果的理解。
研究设计与样本
- THRIVE是一项三臂随机对照试验,旨在评估产前和产后早期干预:增强型婴儿三重P(ETPB)加常规照护或Mellow Bumps(MB)加常规照护,对比单独常规照护。
- 本论文聚焦THRIVE的现实主义过程评估,采用混合方法设计,包括定量测量(培训者与准妈妈培训/干预前后问卷、会后评估表)和定性数据收集方法。
- 定性数据收集方法包括对培训者培训和选定干预组(ETPB组n=3,MB组n=3)一系列产前课程的参与观察、对培训者、孕妇、伴侣和转介培训者的半结构化访谈,以及检查ETPB和MB产后组成部分内容的电话访谈。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: THRIVE is a three-arm randomised controlled trial (RCT) that aims to evaluate whether antenatal and early postnatal interventions, Enhanced Triple B for Baby (ETPB) plus care as usual (CAU) or Mellow Bumps (MB) plus CAU (versus CAU alone), can: 1) improve the mental health and well-being of pregnant women with complex health and social care needs; 2) improve mother-infant bonding and interaction; 3) reduce child maltreatment; and 4) improve child language acquisition. This paper focuses on THRIVE's realist process evaluation, which is carefully monitoring what is happening in the RCT. METHODS: Realistic evaluation provides the theoretical rationale for the process evaluation. We question: 1) how faithfully are MB and ETPB implemented? 2) What are the mechanisms by which they work, if they do, and who do they work for and how? 3) What contextual factors are necessary for the programmes to function, or might prevent them functioning? The mixed-methods design includes quantitative measures, which are pre- and post-training/intervention questionnaires for facilitators and mothers-to-be, and post-session evaluation forms. Qualitative data collection methods include participant observation of facilitator training and the delivery of a series of antenatal sessions in selected intervention groups (n = 3 for ETPB and n = 3 for MB), semi-structured interviews with facilitators, pregnant women, partners, and referring facilitators, and telephone interviews examining the content of the postnatal components of ETPB and MB. DISCUSSION: The findings of this process evaluation will help researchers and decision makers interpret the outcomes of THRIVE. It will provide a greater understanding of: how the interventions work (if they do); the extent and quality of their implementation; contextual factors facilitating and constraining intervention functioning; variations in response within and between subgroups of vulnerable parents; and benefits or unintended consequences of either intervention. Few studies to date have published detailed research protocols illustrating how realist process evaluation is designed and conducted as an integral part of a randomised controlled trial. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN, ISRCTN21656568 . Registered on 8 November 2013.
引用
- O'Brien R, Buston K, Wight D, et al. A realist process evaluation of Enhanced Triple P for Baby and Mellow Bumps, within a Trial of Healthy Relationship Initiatives for the Very Early years (THRIVE): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2019. PMID: 31196169. doi:10.1186/s13063-019-3395-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。