综合现有证据以设计未来试验:对欧洲机构方法学家的调查
该调查通过在线问卷和转介抽样,收集了76名试验统计师、方法学家和证据综合研究使用者对条件试验设计框架的意见。约65%的参与者愿意考虑使用证据综合来设计未来临床试验,约半数会优先考虑此类设计;使用此类设计频率的中位评分为0.41(0表示从不,1表示总是)。主要障碍包括当前监管范式以及资助机构和申办方的政策。
要点
- 76名研究者完成调查,65%愿意考虑使用证据综合设计未来临床试验。
- 约半数参与者会优先考虑此类试验设计。
- 使用此类设计频率的中位评分为0.41(0从不至1总是)。
核心结论
- 参与者对在设计未来试验时使用证据综合方法表现出中等兴趣。
- 参与者表示,在将网络Meta分析常规用于试验设计之前,需要进行重大的范式转变。
研究设计与样本
- 通过转介抽样对试验统计师、方法学家和证据综合研究使用者进行在线调查,共76名研究者完成。
主要发现
- 65%的参与者愿意可能或肯定考虑使用证据综合来设计未来临床试验。
- 约半数参与者会优先考虑此类试验设计。
- 使用此类试验设计频率的中位评分为0.41(量表0表示从不,1表示总是)。
- 采用条件试验设计的主要障碍包括当前监管范式以及资助机构和申办方的政策。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: 'Conditional trial design' is a framework for efficiently planning new clinical trials based on a network of relevant existing trials. The framework considers whether new trials are required and how the existing evidence can be used to answer the research question and plan future research. The potential of this approach has not been fully realized. METHODS: We conducted an online survey among trial statisticians, methodologists, and users of evidence synthesis research using referral sampling to capture opinions about the conditional trial design framework and current practices among clinical researchers. The questions included in the survey were related to the decision of whether a meta-analysis answers the research question, the optimal way to synthesize available evidence, which relates to the acceptability of network meta-analysis, and the use of evidence synthesis in the planning of new studies. RESULTS: In total, 76 researchers completed the survey. Two out of three survey participants (65%) were willing to possibly or definitely consider using evidence synthesis to design a future clinical trial and around half of the participants would give priority to such a trial design. The median rating of the frequency of using such a trial design was 0.41 on a scale from 0 (never) to 1 (always). Major barriers to adopting conditional trial design include the current regulatory paradigm and the policies of funding agencies and sponsors. CONCLUSIONS: Participants reported moderate interest in using evidence synthesis methods in the design of future trials. They indicated that a major paradigm shift is required before the use of network meta-analysis is regularly employed in the design of trials.
引用
- Nikolakopoulou A, Trelle S, Sutton AJ, et al. Synthesizing existing evidence to design future trials: survey of methodologists from European institutions. Trials. 2019. PMID: 31174597. doi:10.1186/s13063-019-3449-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。